I have never seen him sign #2, and if out there, would be very rare. perhaps Steiner has some, but would be very expensive.
as for his signature being "ugly"that is certainly the case with his recent autographs, but if you can land one from the mid to late 90's they are much nicer.
here is a decent one, just not sure if the #2 was penned by Jeter:
your call. the current Jeter Steiner signatures are awful, in my opinion. but if that is what you want, and if he is willing to add No. 2, then go for it.
if it were me, I would prefer to have a nice, vintage Jeter signature that would cost less than half the amount that one thru steiner would cost, and it would be a nicer signature.
as for the #2 above, as I mentioned, I have no idea if that is in Jeter's handwriting. Probably not.