Let me explain--this has provenance. Bought years ago from the woman at that time in her 60's in MO who said she got this in person by all 3 on an album page after the concert Feb 1958. I had emailed a copy of the graphs to either buddy Holly's brother in law or Cousin (thin the former) who examined it and rendered opinion "I have turned down a whole lot, this looks like it is probably the real deal and I can tell you exactly what date it was signed as Buddy only went thru kansas City One day in 1958:.    That was about 20 years ago.   two years ago I showed it to PSA and they immediately said :NO GOOD....but I had also shown PSA a REAL Crosby Stills nash Young LP signed in front of me (all 4) and they said "NO GOOD" > isaid how can al album I saw signed bye a FAIL. They said it didnt match THEIR examples. i said then YOUR examples are BOGUS because I have gotten CSNY since 1986 and i KNOW their graphs.. SO--i leave it to you--is this GOOD...Buddy's brother in law said "they key to a GOOD Holly graph is he signs his name in 3 separate parts and puts a LOOP in the H". I looked at what i have...and It has the Loop and is signed in 3 parts. The other 2 band members also look good to me.  OPINIONS?

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

There is provenance on the Dylan...it was signed for Peter Plank who served in Government I beleive in kansas or Oklahoma in the 70's.  It was signed around 1975 Opinions? DYLAN is very hard to identidy but a pre 80's example might be easier..this is signed between 74-76. I beleive it to be REAL which would real DYlan I own..if yoour opinions are GOOD. i aheb MET Dylan 4 times and just FINDING him is a real task...he refused all 4 times I met him in the strangest ways. ive NEVER seen him touch a pen...i dont beleive anything on ebay ANY dealer is selling is real. I got this in 1984.