We're an eBay affiliate and may be compensated on purchases made through clicks. 

Just got a Gotham poster off ebay cast signed. Did a quick opinion through PSA and GA

Came back from PSA likely not genuine and from GA likely genuine. Compared signatures to known PSA certified ones and they look legit to me.

Soon as I get this in I would like to send out to get authenticated. Who do you recommend?

JSA, PSA or GA. Or any others?

Here is a list of the autographs

 1. Ben McKenzie……James Gordon 

 2 Donal Logue……Harvey Bullock

 3.  David Mazouz……Bruce Wayne (AKA Batman)

 4.  Sean Pertwee……Alfred Pennyworth

 5.  Robin Lord Taylor……Oswald Cobblepot (AKA The Penguin)

 6.  Camren Bicondova……Selina Kyle (AKA Catwoman)

 7.  Cory Michael Smith……Edward Nygma (AKA The Riddler)

 8.  Nicholas D'Agosto……Harvey Dent (AKA Two Face)

 9.  Jada Pinkett Smith……Fish Mooney

10.  John Doman……Carmine Falcone

11.  Erin Richards……Barbara Kean

12.  Zabryna Guevara……Sarah Essen

13.  Victoria Cartagena……Renee Montoya

14.  Andrew Stewart-Jones……Crispus Allen

15.  Danny Cannon……Producer, Director, Writer

16.  Bruno Heller……Producer, Writer

17.  John Stephens……Producer, Writer

Thanks for your insight.

Jason

Tags: (AKA, 1., 10., 11., 12., 13., 14., 15., 16., 17., More…2., 3., 4., 5., 6., 7., 8., 9., Allen, Andrew, Batman, Batman), Ben, Bicondova……Selina, Bruno, Bullock, Camren, Cannon……Producer, Cartagena……Renee, Catwoman), Cobblepot, Cory, D'Agosto……Harvey, Danny, David, Dent, Director, Doman……Carmine, Donal, Erin, Essen, Face), Falcone, Gordon, Gotham, Guevara……Sarah, Heller……Producer, Jada, John, Kean, Kyle, Logue……Harvey, Lord, Mazouz……Bruce, McKenzie……James, Michael, Montoya, Mooney, Nicholas, Nygma, Penguin), Pennyworth, Pertwee……Alfred, Pinkett, Richards……Barbara, Riddler), Robin, Sean, Smith……Edward, Smith……Fish, Stephens……Producer, Stewart-Jones……Crispus, Taylor……Oswald, The, Two, Victoria, Wayne, Writer, Zabryna

Views: 2859

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

That is good to know I did not realize there were any changes at JSA.  I never have used them but  I know a lot of the classic entertainment autographs I have seen in the past were good,   I think Tom Kramer was working there then and he is one of the best in regards to classic entertainment.  I hope they are still using him on those.  I think Mr. Epperson used to work there too.  So they certainly had good people the question is how often do they actually use them. 

If I was working for PSA and doing a $10 quick opinion on this piece.

I doubt I'd read the description.

I'd Look at the McKenzie the Pertwee, the Logue and the Jada.

McKenzie is spaced wrong, Logue looks ok, Jada signed her full name at SDCC last summer, and Pertwee is a toss up.

All that along with a same pen, and not a bump or bruise on the poster.

Results: FAIL

Hopefully you would say you couldn't determine authenticity. Otherwise this poster could have been thrown out. Sad but true

Thanks Pete,

I do realize $10.00 is not a lot of money and not worth a lot of time. But I really do hope they look and don't just say. Looks like another fake poster we get a hundred of these a week.

Your right on the Jada. The poster on display on the golden apple comics website shows the name the same way. And a couple weeks ago I posted this picture in a thread you replied to. Maybe she got sick of signing so much gotham stuff. She did only sign for 1 season of filming and is done with show now.

Hunt down one of these lesser known actors or one of the writers who signed it, find an email address and ask if they actually signed it.  If they say "yeah we just signed 8 of these posters for a giveaway" then there you go.  That's better provenance than random photos of the event anyway.

I agree with Mike's suggestion.  Contact one of the lesser known characters on FB or Twitter and see if they can back the story up.  That Jada looks nothing like what I've gotten from her.  Even though the poster is on display behind them still doesn't mean the store purchased/acquired 8 fake posters and used them to raffle off.

Update just got an email back from Golden Apple's owner confirming 8 were given away. I will print out and save along with everything else.

-----Original Message-----
From: GA Orders <orders@goldenapplecomics.com>
To: fishworlderie <fishworlderie@aol.com>
Sent: Sat, Jun 13, 2015 2:21 pm
Subject: Re: Question

Yes. 8 given away at a raffle during the event. You can see the poster behind them in one of the pictures in the link I sent.
Ryan - Owner Golden Apple

On Jun 13, 2015, at 10:18 AM, fishworlderie@aol.com wrote:

Golden Apple,

Just trying to confirm. There were 8 of these gotham cast signed posters handed out?
I am trying to document all the provenance I can. The more the better. If you have any other provenance that would be great.

Thanks,

Jason Ortiz


If it were me, I wouldn't feel happy having this in my collection, unless there was some decent provenance behind it. Otherwise, not for me. :)

RSS

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2024   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service