We're an eBay affiliate and may be compensated on purchases made through clicks. 

Any opinions on this please?

Signed at LIPA.

Thank you

Views: 1020

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Looks OK to me...IMO...

Thanks Jim.

It looks good to me too.

Great.  Thanks Ballroom.

I like it too.

Brilliant.  Thanks Steve. 

Now up for sale on the Buy/Sell page.

Maybe I'm wrong, and I don't mean to rock the boat, but I say no.

Look at the slow connection between "P" and "a". Paul never writes that slowly.  The first and second "c" are done slowly in that the signer changed how he held the pen. Paul signs quickly. I've never seen that "grip change" before. The underline has an unusual bend in it.  

It may have been signed at LIPA - but, by who? 

I thought I might be the only one who didn’t like this autograph. I don’t like the flow and especially the P to a  transition in Paul. Also do not like the end of McCartney and the underline just looks wrong to me. 

frankly, I do not like it either.  it looks too neat. just doesn't look right to me.  I compared to others and technically, it matches up favorably, but I still have concerns.

As the seller of the aforementioned item I can see some valid points raised.  Usually I would bow down to your superior knowledge on any Beatles related item really but in this case you are incorrect.

It was signed 25th July 2013 in the main rehearsal room.  It was signed for a family friend and ex LIPA student and bought by me last year.  He didn’t sign many and he only signed for her because she lived off Menlove Avenue she made him laugh.....  I have absolutely no reason to doubt her and her provenance.  OK I didn’t actually see it being signed but I saw I picture of it an hour after it was signed and I chased her for it since.  My theory of it being ‘too neat’ is that it was signed in a calm environment and not a rushed on the street signing.

Anyway I have refunded the buyer after his request.

Thank you.

Then why did you seek opinions?  If I look at the sky, see the sun and no clouds, I don't need to ask someone if they think it's about to rain. If it gets windy and dark clouds start to show up, that's a different story. 

Compare this Paul,  which was signed in his office, also a non-rushed situation. 

Attachments: No photo uploads here

RSS

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2024   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service