We're an eBay affiliate and may be compensated on purchases made through clicks. 

Views: 1774

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

The o and y of Courtney looks like it took whomever signed it the entire day to write those letters. The tail of the y has so many stopping points, the line varying in width, that I can't even count the stops.

Just a thought; is there any chance that the piece didn't actually meet its reserve at auction or was "bought" by the original owner?  

that's why I posted it but what happens a lot people who no clue just post what the person posted in front of him without really knowing

people who just want to be seen as knowing will post also not real or real that's my point

nirvana is one of the hardest bands to authenticate

u just said u don't know there sigs

And by your own words, John, you spent 3 yrs with the band and are still only 50/50 and posting for opinions.

So based on your words, there’s a 50% chance Im right and these are fake, yes?

Spending time with the band obviously doesnt make you an expert. 

And just bc you want to believe something is real, doesnt invalidate someone else’s observations or make them less able to use their own eyeballs.

With my own eyes, these sigs give me MAJOR cause for concern WITHOUT even studying. I wouldnt buy them for that reason alone.

Why do they all look done by the same hand?

Why does Courtney sign as if shes unsure of her own first name? Wait...maybe she was f....d up like you said, but then got sober by the time she signed her last name?

Why does the Hole guy curve his sig to stay on the clear border? Sober or f....d up, I wouldnt expect a grunge rock star to be so careful and deliberate.

Is there a chance Im wrong? Sure. Im no expert, just offering my own opinions - not parroting anyone. 

You posted for opinions. Opinions you got. Just bc you dont LIKE the opinions you got doesnt mean they arent valid concerns to other collectors or people interested in Nirvana sigs. 

Personally, I wouldnt touch these sigs with a 50 ft. pole, thats all.

And the last sale speaks volumes.

Come to think of it, an authentic set of Nirvana and Hole that was bought for 3500 and then sold for 1000 makes all the sense in the world.

NOT.

You really don't even have to know their signatures. The fact that the same hand wrote them supersedes any discussion of individual authenticity. To me, it looks as though someone simply wrote a list of band members names, much like a laundry list. Whether or not they were striving for an authentic look is of no consideration as the same person wrote them.

That's a great poster!

so actualy heard back from the original first sale of the poster a former music exuctive with 30 years in the bussinees at major lables

he said its real as his letter statesthat came with the poster when sold

so the mystery goes on

I wont name the guy but hes well know to steve and  other few around here. as I said it comes with 3 different letters .

just interested to see if we can prove it one way or another

Was this for sale at recordmecca?

That is very interesting

And that's all I'm going to say

I agree 

its a mystery and as I said it comes with a bunch of lime time guarentees from people we all know

I still have no clue why anyone would fake the other bands sigs it doesnt really do much for the value and gives 6 more chances to fu*k it up

also its signed by Gary Floyd of Sister Double Happiness  wich adds no value at all but gives  another chance to f*** up a sig if fake

ps theres not many examples of some of these people for even to copy from

it sold in 2015 for 3500$ and then it flipped recently for 1k wich is wierd because it has life time guarentees and the last sale was not  at an  auction house.

Those are very weird chain of pricing for a so called authentic piece.

It makes sense if it was proven Fake though.

I really don't know what else to say about it

I agree 

but why not just return it

and why add 5 extra graphs that don't do much 

as a unsigned flyer its 500 to 1k alone

pss I don't own it.just seeing what the real soty is as I have the backstory

I try to keep track of signed nirvana concert posters because there very few

that's why this site is good and im sure somebody will eventualy be posting it for ioppinions when it flips again

RSS

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2024   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service