Hi everyone, I was hoping to get some opinions on this Harry Houdini signature. It is signed on a book page....sorry for the pic quality. I didn't see any red flags but I am certainly no expert. Thanks!! 

Views: 333

Attachments:

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Be patient, as there are a couple on here, who are Good with Houdini. I only have 7 signatures to compare this one to. Mine are from the late 1880's and 1890's, so I really can't say for sure. It does have some characteristics of Houdini's Signature, but also has some big differences. These could have changed over the years, as I believe this one is from 1908? Just don't have any from this period to compare with.

Thanks for the reply. Yes, this is dated 1908, so his signature certainly could have varied from the 1880's until then.

It looks like you're posting an image in a printed catalog, is that right?

I haven't studied Houdini deeply, but that autograph has strong Houdini characteristics to me, and I compared it to some period exemplars to confirm my opinion. I would be surprised if he didn't sign it.

Thanks for taking a look, Steve. It was an ebay listing that I recently won. The listing stated that the book actually belonged to Houdini. I am not too concerned about whether or not he owned it, but I definitely want to make sure that the signature is good. Thanks again for your opinion!

Darryl.

I'm concerned because the image appears to be out of a catalog, not the actual book. Do you have more photos?

Regular PayPal will protect you but it's best to know for sure from the start.

The ebay listing (dndgalleries, an antique book dealer, is the seller) did have more pictures of the book. I just took a picture of my computer screen with a closeup of the signature and posted it, which is why it isn't the best picture.

I managed to get my hands on a Harry Houdini signature from 1909 and 1911. Comparing these with the one you listed, I feel pretty safe in saying, this is not an Authentic Signature. Sorry....

Tim,

Please post the Houdini signature you found from the time period. Darryl's looks very likely genuine to me, so I'd like to see if I'm missing something. Thanks

Here are the 2 that I mentioned, Steve. (1909-1911)..

One thing that I have realized while doing research on Houdini's signature is that they seem to vary quite a bit. Even the two pics posted from 1909 and 1911 vary quite a bit, and they are only 2 years apart. I am not even 100% sure that the autograph that I posted was signed in 1908, assuming that it is authentic. If this was indeed Houdini's personal copy he could have easily added the signature, location and date that he obtained the book at a much later time. That may be a little far fetched, but possible.

There's only 1 year apart on the 1908-1909 signatures. Anything is possible? I based my Opinion on the signatures above and the 1908 date on the signature in question...It will be increasingly difficult, trying to match this signature to many different time periods, for comparison. You may watch to just pay for a QO, so you will have a professional opinion as well??

I tried a PSA Quick Opinion but they would not render an opinion. They said that I would need to send it in which I will probably do. It will cost me around $150 total but if it fails I will be able to get a refund through paypal.

RSS

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2009-2017   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Community Manager.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service