We're an eBay affiliate and may be compensated on purchases made through clicks. 

I am reaching out to get feedback on my Paul McCartney PSA authenticated cut.  A member of this group suggested I post it for a general consensus, no matter how painful it may be.  I am looking to sell it, but just can't screw someone over, if in fact, I've been screwed.  Anyway, here is a pic.

Views: 1573

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Sorry Carl lol....I could be wrong.lets see what others have to say.

I still think it's fine. It's an old piece of paper with an old pen. The autograph is a 1980s version. Controversial and rushed,  yes. Fake, no. If I had it, I'd consider upgrading. 

I want to try and sell it and save up for a better one, but it is very important to me that my reputation be solid.  I don't want to be looked at as someone selling fake s***.  If only it wasn't originally authenticated through PSA and be in the database etc. this conversation would never be happening as I would never have even considered picking it up.  Ugh.

It looks like a Joe Long forgery to me. Here it is followed by two known Joe Long forgeries.

Here’s a George signature that apparently was authenticated at the same time as the Macca in the OP. To me it also appears to be a Long forgery.

I recently heard back from Roger via email stating that he doesn't believe it to be a Joe Long job, but, that his opinion is that it isn't authentic.  So it's not looking so good.

I wonder what he would think of the George signature.

I believe that whoever signed the PSA'd signature in the OP, also signed the two  posted by Ballroom.  the Paul is different in each case, but the McCartney is virtually identical.  I am not familiar with Long's style, but I trust Ballroom if he says it is.  The bottom line is it is likely NOT authentic.

Agree with what Terrier said. I think what Ballroom said was right. After looking at the other two examples that Ballroom showed I can clearly see that they are all in the same hand. 

Joe Long Beatles "signatures...

One of the Pauls I posted was taken from the top set. Compare the George to the PSA one.

The George is almost a match.that would lead u to believe that  the Paul and George are long forgeries.

I agree. It’s easier to see it when you look at both together.

RSS

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2024   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service