Needing Some Opinions on These Mickey Mantle Autos

I don’t know if this is taboo here but instead of writing a different post for each Mantle autograph, I’ve posted 3 different autographs that I’ve purchased online as a singular discussion, and am hoping to once again get some opinions from you knowledgeable Mantle auto experts who I’ve grown to trust more than any PSA, JSA, who’s agendas are at the very least suspect.

I think I’m starting to better recognize the nuances of Mickeys signature but I am certainly still an amateur enthusiast at best. I’ve posted pics of 3 different purchases of which I paid about $100 total which is a red flag in my mind from the get go. Is this one of those if it seems to good to Be true......

I thank you all ahead of time for your opinions and if you do think these look good, how are they selling for so little ? Anyway, thanks again!

Rob

9AA7C781-83C3-4A0F-A1F1-6F91B32604F9.jpeg

CDC6769B-ACC5-4EA8-A0FE-7190D7FF9B3E.jpeg

70B3C4CB-0DCC-4E68-A95E-E16FEBC499CD.jpeg

#2 8A274CB4-2C21-45F5-BA70-637D652609CF.jpeg

7CD4AD25-B7FB-4C83-8F58-3E8CB663A8E6.jpeg

B90F18BE-DF03-4747-AEA3-1357FC0FC949.jpeg

#3EAB96A13-0499-4621-A32E-FECF06FF209B.jpeg

3D8427DA-41CD-4296-B4EE-0D557A0BCF81.png

Tags: Mantle, Mickey

0 members like this

▶ Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Steve on November 20, 2019 at 9:13am

#1 looks good, #2 looks ok, but a little hard to see well, #3 fake.

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Steve Zarelli on November 20, 2019 at 10:42am

I avoiding commenting unless I feel pretty confident in my opinion. I'll admit I looked these over and was less certain than I like to be, and I usually have a strong command of Mantle.

The hard right slant on #1 bothers me.

#2 was inconclusive due to poor contrast.

#3 not good in my opinion.

I suggest seeking more opinions on #1.