Edward Siebert
  • Wellngton
  • New Zealand
Share on Facebook

Edward Siebert's Friends

  • Pete Chuka
  • Beatleworld

Edward Siebert's Discussions

My little Muhammad Ali story, and big autograph surprise

Started this discussion. Last reply by terrier8HOF Jun 5, 2016. 3 Replies

Back in 1987, when I was 15 years old, I wrote to Muhammad Ali asking for an autograph. This is what he sent back. At the time, I thought it was really unique, and really special. Over the years I…Continue

Tags: Ali, Muhammad

Jimmy Carter signed photo -- thoughts?

Started May 1, 2014 0 Replies

I received this signed photo from President Carter in about 1985. It has always looked a little fishy to me, most notably the 'my' in his first name (which are not as defined as they usually are) and…Continue


Edward Siebert's Page

Latest Activity

Edward Siebert replied to Cris AutoCollector99's discussion Authentic Jackie Kennedy signed letter???
"I don't think this letter is real. The writing and signature are not right."
Mar 18
Edward Siebert replied to Tim H's discussion George W. Bush Signed Photo
"It's not an autopen, and not a pre-print, looks good."
Mar 7
Edward Siebert replied to fab432's discussion Beatles Maybe and a Set by Neil Aspinall
"Neither set is authentic, first set for sure by Neil."
Mar 6
Edward Siebert replied to Mike Shepherd's discussion Star Wars Collectors Unite!
"Is anyone going to the Star Wars Celebration in Orlando in mid April? If so, if I paid for your ticket would you be willing to go and have Ian McDiarmid sign my RotJ poster? I have most of the cast but really want him. I live in New Zealand and…"
Mar 2
Edward Siebert replied to GregJ's discussion What Do You Guys Think Of This Eisenhower?
"Looks good to me"
Feb 25
Edward Siebert replied to Greg's discussion New RR Auctions Site??
"Hate their new website. Of as easy to navigate, and not as logically set up. Very disappointed."
Feb 23
Edward Siebert replied to GregJ's discussion Richard Nixon - Real or Fake?
"This is authentic."
Feb 20
Edward Siebert replied to Gareth's discussion John Balushi
"Agree, this isn't authentic."
Feb 11
Edward Siebert replied to Dylan Fritch's discussion Authentic Richard Nixon signature, possibly?
"Looks very much like an autopen to me."
Dec 31
Edward Siebert replied to GregJ's discussion Jackie Kennedy - Real or Fake?
"Sorry, this is not real, in my opinion. Both the writing -- which was bigger, bolder and quite distinct -- and the signature are worn."
Dec 31
Edward Siebert commented on Pete Chuka's blog post Star Wars Autographs by the Numbers: Which are the Rarest?
"It's a very sad day in the Star Wars universe today, but I wanted to say how much I loved this whole post and conversation. Thanks Pete!"
Dec 27, 2016
Edward Siebert replied to GregJ's discussion Andy Warhol - Real or fake?
"Looks good to me."
Dec 27, 2016
Edward Siebert replied to Getreel's discussion Elvis signed pic hanging in barbershop
"It's not real, sorry"
Dec 13, 2016
Edward Siebert replied to James Stone's discussion Real JFK auto signed after he was assassinated
"It's like the several dozen White House 1963 Christmas cards he and Jackie signed the day before they left for Dallas."
Dec 6, 2016
Edward Siebert replied to Greg's discussion Harry S. Truman
"I haven't often heard of him using a secretarial signature...but that is one. That is definitely not a real Truman autograph, especially from the 1940s."
Dec 5, 2016
Edward Siebert replied to David Wilkie's discussion Single-signed Beatles memorabilia
"Yes, unfortunately that is not even close to any Beatles' signature."
Dec 5, 2016

About Me

What kind of member are you? Industry professionals must use their real names and identify themselves as such. (Check as many as apply.)
What brings you to Autograph Live?
Been an active autograph collector for 30 years
Who can we thank for telling you about Autograph Live?
What do you collect, or want to collect?
Sports, History/Politics, Music
Tell us more about your collection, specific areas of interest, etc.:
Presidents, Beatles
What is your level of expertise?
Advanced Collector, Long Time Lover
What is your favorite autograph in your collection?
Book signed by 7 presidents
Why do you collect?
Not sure...a way to have a very small piece of people I admire
You can ask anyone living or dead for their autograph. Who would it be?
John Lennon, Abraham Lincoln

Comment Wall

You need to be a member of Autograph Live to add comments!

Join Autograph Live

  • No comments yet!

© 2009-2017   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Community Manager.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service