Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Joshua Maloney on July 11, 2020 at 7:26pm

Josh,

Be very careful with this Harry Potter book. This is the work of a very good forger called Primusfan1. I actually purchased this a few years ago, I thought it was good when I sold it, but after some serious conversations with Carly Jaddoa, who is a Potter expert, (look up all the pretty books) this book is not in fact authentically signed. I am currently working to get this book removed from eBay, (and get the original buyer a refund) with Carly's help. Remember that just because a book has a sticker from one of the big three, doesn't mean it really is authentic.  they make mistakes, especially with Rowling. It passed my tests, as it does look really good, but according to Carly this is a fake. If you have questions about Potter books your best bet is to reach out to Carly. I am not to certain on why this is fake (which is part of why I sold it originally, I was sure it was real) but Carly, who is an expert, says no good, and she has one of the best eyes for Rowling.

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Josh on July 12, 2020 at 3:28am

Thanks very much yea even before you told me I did my research and I couldn’t get the j out of my head for being fake but I messaged jsa they told me it was real then I found Carly myself but watching YouTube videos and she had this book On the fake list I was surprised how many books I found that were fake man their is a lot 

• ▶ Reply