PAAS is garbage, and CAS is a newer company that seems to have its share of issues. I'd put little value in either authentication and question why they used two two different services, neither of which seem to be highly regarded. The other question is where they got it. Someone obviously went through the effort of getting these signed in two different sharpie paint pens at a show(s), so that information should be somewhere.
This is old news even with other tpa's I've seen over time authenticating these sports people incorrectly.