Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Steven Jackson on August 30, 2012 at 3:02pm

Hey Gary thanks for posting this I think it is a neat idea but in my opinion  can't see this being used for autographs for a few reasons 1. the price the cost of an 8x10 is only a buck or so, then theres needing to have the star sign in the special pen that in a rush someone big enough to invest in such an item like paul mccartney  would not take the time to use the pen.

I can also see that the signature dosent pop be a problem for some as i know myself like to be able to display and read the autograph and the bold standout signatures tend to bring more money in the market place.

also with this type of idea im not sure if it would help or hurt, but i could see these being filled with forgeries or some type reproduction signatures.

Just my opinion i still like it's idea as a guest book great idea there.

 

steve

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Rich on August 30, 2012 at 3:25pm

I'll agree with Steven.  Interesting thought.  Let us know what the outcome of the DragonCon experiment is.

There just seem to be a couple problems with translating this to the autograph market:

1) If you're getting autographs on the street, especially in a crowd, this will be especially problematic.  Many celebs use the same sharpie someone already let them use, often when they're in a hurry.  Getting them to use a specific pen can be a chore on many occasions.  This type of autograph would be pretty much for controlled environments - i.e. autograph shows, conventions, private signings, etc. - or on other ideal circumstance when there is little to no crowd.

2) Collectors generally want photos, baseballs, LP's, jerseys, posters - really neat looking things signed.  A sheet of metal could be a tough sell.  If a certain product line of etchable items comes out (i.e. metal mini helmets for instance), that might work.  On the other hand, that could get expensive and be less visually appealling anyway. 

3) Re-selling could be a trick.  Collectors and fans will look at this and instantly think that an engraved item can't possibly be an authentic signature.

 

• ▶ Reply