IMO cut signatures are a slippery slope. Especially Babe Ruth...it's so much easier to forge on old paper and cut the best ones. George Reeves, he's been gone for almost 60 years...so it's extremely tough to judge. When you bought it, he was gone 42 years. I don't think you'd get any reasonable offers if you didn't find an authenticator or 2 to give these a look. Good luck!