Autograph Live

The Authentic Experience


  Anyone with a solid expertise with Boris Karloff, take a look at this photo.   I have collected his autograph for over 25 years.  Also I sent to someone I consider the  credible expert on Boris Karloff and Bela Lugosi.   But just curious to hear opinions here.

Views: 2814

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion


UPdate:   This Karloff came from a long time collectors estate around early-late 1930s.   Here are some of the other photos in the collection inscribed to same person.   The Jean Harlow is as usual Mama Jeans signature


































































Nice piece! I can dig up a large image if you'd like, but here's a Karloff SP we published in a March 2010 feature. Yours looks very much like it. What's interesting is that this one has both versions of the "B" that common?


The looped "B" Is less common.   Surprising this photo you show has Both versions.  I believe that is the one sold by R&R in 2008.  What I am finding is his very early signatures early-mid 1930's had the loop version and also the "o" in Boris and Karloff is more pronounced, where his later much shakier signatures excluded the "o"s and other letters were much shakier and less legible.

Close! R&R 2004. Here's a larger pic:

Correct Steve. The 2008 was another less attractive glossy Karloff/Frank signed photo



I have got mostly very positive feedback on the signature .  But, as was the case with the John Wayne and JFK case studies I posted a couple months ago, I did get a very bizarre response from one of the well known dealers/auctions.   My background with Karloff/Lugosi is strong but I am hoping to get some other "eyes with expertise" on this.


I'm not surprised the feedback was good--but glad to hear it. Re, the bizarre response: do you want to share it without revealing their name? (Unless you think they wouldn't mind you publishing it.)


I don't want to disparage anyone's name or business and create a flame war here.  They are good guys , even though I sometimes disagree with their findings.   I know dealers and auction houses have their own objectives that can leave us scratching our heads sometimes, but I like to exchange expertise and many of these guys are helpful, even when our opinions greatly differ.  I can discuss with you via PM.


P.S.  We are all going by a scan until I actually get the photo Wednesday.  I will scan a large image of the signature and inscription and upload here.  Particularly to see if the ink is vintage  and consistent with the time period, which based on this and the other photos in collection is early-mid 1930s.   However, what I am already seeing is a "dead on" match to not only the signatures but especially the "Best Wishes" in many PSA Karloff photos including the one you posted above.

I agree, the last thing you want is a flame war here...particularly among legit parties. That's why anonymous would be fine. Let's leave it for now...thanks.

hey Kevin,

if everyone agrees that this is good, and I am not sure either way, I'd pay BIG for this!


I have shown it privately to nine experienced collectors and dealers.  Eight say unquestionably genuine. One in particular is the guy I have gone to for the past ten years who only collects Lugosi/Karloff and has a very "gifted" eye and knowledge of  good/bad items on the market.  

One dealer said a "hint of suspicion".  But it wasn't based on comments of inconsistency, but of  "it's too good to be true" opinion.    Such as "do you really think Karloff would sign in that perfect of a location and have such perfect contrast" and also doubted a photo this "amazing" would be signed by Karloff.

I have a UCLA yearbook from the late 20s, where Boris Karloff is pictured in. He was the cricket coach for the school. Very strange.


That signature looks good to me, from the ones I've seen over the years.


(I'm a huge boxing fan -- wanna sell the Max Baer photo?)


Blog Posts

Top 5 Risky Space Autographs by Zarelli Space Authentication

Posted by Steve Zarelli on October 8, 2015 at 7:27am 1 Comment

What are the top five most dangerous space autographs? What space autograph is fake 75% of the time in my opinion? You may be surprised at some of the names.

I wrote the attached article for the Fall 2014 edition of the…


Another Celebrity Car -- The James Dean Edition

Posted by Josh Board on October 2, 2015 at 11:57pm 6 Comments

I remember 10 years ago going into the Hard Rock…


More Famous Cars -- the Jack Kevorkian Edition

Posted by Josh Board on September 27, 2015 at 10:48pm 0 Comments

Since I recently wrote about the automobiles of Keith…


Musicians signing in September. Some yes, some no, some disappear.

Posted by Coachgd on September 25, 2015 at 6:53pm 4 Comments

September has been a pretty good month for adding to the collection.  Things started to slow down in Northeast Ohio, but I still managed to get a few good ones.

Todd Rundgren made his 5th appearance in Northern Ohio in the past…


Autographs on Late Shows -- Stephen Colbert with Donald Trump, Jimmy Kimmel with James Taylor

Posted by Josh Board on September 24, 2015 at 9:59am 0 Comments

A few of the late night shows have had autograph things…


Presidential Autographs and Handwriting Analysis

Posted by Josh Board on September 21, 2015 at 9:37pm 4 Comments

When Autograph Magazine could be found in newsstands everywhere, I enjoyed writing columns and stories for the publication. I still love writing the blogs.

Steve Cyrkin brought in a lot of interesting people to write for the…


Does EBay Now Permit Shill Bidding?

Posted by Christopher Williams on September 19, 2015 at 1:30pm 14 Comments

A little over a month ago I sent an email to Ebay about obvious shill bidding.

Of course, Ebay never responded.

This has been going on for…


Brandes autographs charity auction for Vietnam and Syria refugees

Posted by Markus Brandes on September 18, 2015 at 1:00am 2 Comments

napalm girl





© 2009-2015   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Community Manager.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service