Now that I have more info on this item, where do I sell this thing? I hate eBay! Anyone can try to pass anything off as authentic and real items are overlooked for cheaper possibly faked things. Any thoughts?
If all the autographs on your Metallica album are real, you've got a valuable piece on your hands. First things first--get it authenticated unless you're planning to consign it to auction. I'd get a quick opinion from Roger Epperson for $15 and if he says it's good, then go for the full COA. You can send it to PSA/DNA or JSA, but it will take longer to get the COA, and Roger's is highly respected.
Then put it in our Buy/Sell/Trade group or on eBay, and don't settle for less than top dollar unless there's unusual wear or damage. You have a rare and highly desirable find.