We're an eBay affiliate and may be compensated on purchases made through clicks. 

Obtained a few months ago when Sir Paul was in New York City (according to the in person autograph seller).   Thanks for your thoughts!

Views: 1572

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

definitely authentic, IMO

Thanks for your opinion.  Was told it passed PSA's "Quick Opinion" but JSA said "Inconclusive" because their Beatles expert wasn't available at the time.  Kinda strange to hear that though.

Roger Epperson is JSA's music expert, including Beatles.

my opinion is it is real,

Funny -- I just sent this to PSA for their "Quick Opinion" and they said it was no good!

Now, I'm probably going to return it but I also think it's real. 

Anyone else have problems with their quick opinion service?

Steve,

I am not their expert, how dare you say that!

This is not authentic; it was signed by the Philly forgers without a doubt.  I know their work.

Very surprised to hear it's a forgery as I obtained from signatureking023 on ebay who has many other items with JSA Certs (including a Beatles '65 and Beatles with Tony Sheridan LPs up there now) and some Springsteens --  and he SWORE to me he got Paul in person a few months ago in NYC where he signed these.  The Hard Day's Night looks similar to the others to the untrained eye.   Your thoughts Roger?

There is absolutely no question in my mind that this is signed by the Philly forgers>  i will check the ebay id now and get to the bottom of this

Now hold on a minute> the ones on Ebay say "guaranteed to pass JSA" not that they were passed by JSA!  is that what this one said too?  if so please show me the proof as the MMT Macca LP is also signed by the Philly forgers.

The two McCartney's that he has on ebay right now. (Item numbers 170821033597 and 80858775613) come with the JSA COAs (pictured in the listing). The one I bought (Hard Day's Night - item # 180983540752) did say "guaranteed to pass"  JSA or PSA.   I will returning it as I paid on Paypal and he said he would honor the return policy.

I just talked with Jimmy at JSA and I did find 2 other maccas on EBAY with their cert.  This will be taken care of tomorrow i assure you.  thanks for bringing this to my attention

RSS

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2024   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service