Yeah, they both look good to me. I have one done in person and one bought, and I was offered the one above. Looks good to me but someone else didn't think so, so just chasing opinions. The signatures look like what I have on the one I had done in person, but different sizes, and the the ones you showed me look like the sigs above too. It's hard to tell.
Thanks - they're recent ones too. I have some in person pieces myself that look just like the ones you've shown. I also have an older Rumours and the sigs do look different these days. Especially Lindsey.
What do you make of this? Here's a signed Tusk from RR Auction followed by one of the several fully-signed items offered for sale from Rock Star Gallery. The letter of provenance was included with the RR example.