goodcat's Discussions (2,898)

View

Discussions Replied To (2497)	Replies	Latest Activity
"Crapola " goodcat replied May 24, 2018 to Interesting Madonna	2	May 25, 2018 Reply by James
"Bad macca Probstsein123 getting more suspicious " goodcat replied May 24, 2018 to McCartney and Starr "Signed" Photo and Abbey Road LP from Probstein123 with PSA/DNA LOAs - Very surprising!	52	Feb 26, 2019 Reply by BallroomDays67
"If I recall correctly, this seller was discussed awhile ago in selling fake certed c…" goodcat replied May 24, 2018 to Mantle forgery by Probstein123 I'm a little shocked	32	May 29, 2018 Reply by John Spillane
"Pics 1 and 2 don't look like any sig example I have seen. Not even close. Pics 3 an…" goodcat replied May 24, 2018 to Various Madonna	1	May 24, 2018 Reply by goodcat
"Please explain Ringo's importance as you see it" goodcat replied May 23, 2018 to What's new in your collection?	6231	Jan 25 Reply by Eric Keith Longo
"Good response Adam Ask as many opinions as possible. If all eyes agree then the pur…" goodcat replied May 23, 2018 to TRACKS authentication general question	27	May 23, 2018 Reply by Richard Booth
"Looks like a real forgery to me " goodcat replied May 23, 2018 to opinions on this Michael Jackson	2	May 25, 2018 Reply by wascher
"Agree with RichardNo question it's a "NO" from me as well" goodcat replied May 22, 2018 to Elvis Presley	6	May 23, 2018 Reply by terrier8HOF
"a good attempt but still not good enough Each one has has it's flaws Back to the dra…" goodcat replied May 21, 2018 to Pink Floyd opinion	4	May 22, 2018 Reply by MarkG
"great score on that vintage madonna, congrats its a real beauty and good price" goodcat replied May 18, 2018 to Some BIG NUMBERS at the John Brennan / RR Auction	34	May 21, 2018 Reply by a pug called eva