Edward Siebert's Discussions (398)

View

Discussions Replied To (387)	Replies	Latest Activity
"Not real, and very forced and labored attempt. It doesn't flow at all, like real exa…" Edward Siebert replied Nov 5, 2015 to Another Paul McCartney	4	Nov 6, 2015 Reply by Jim Cushman
"A terrible forgery, sorry" Edward Siebert replied Nov 5, 2015 to Paul McCartney Signed Book	6	Nov 6, 2015 Reply by terrier8HOF
"Beutiful" Edward Siebert replied Oct 23, 2015 to My Beatles set framed	17	Nov 16, 2015 Reply by Chris milner
"The only two I can really see are the Ringo and the George, and those two look good…" Edward Siebert replied Oct 23, 2015 to 1963 autographs beatles . Stones etc	3	Oct 23, 2015 Reply by Edward Siebert
"Yuck, both terrible forgeries." Edward Siebert replied Oct 22, 2015 to Thoughts on these 2 Paul McCartney Albums	31	Oct 24, 2015 Reply by terrier8HOF
"Looks pretty good" Edward Siebert replied Oct 21, 2015 to Lennon Harrison Starr Genuine?	5	Oct 22, 2015 Reply by Jim Cushman
"Yep, real" Edward Siebert replied Oct 16, 2015 to David Prowse	3	Oct 16, 2015 Reply by Hugh Costra
"The one in your original post could be real, but it doesn't look good to me. The P a…" Edward Siebert replied Oct 10, 2015 to Paul McCartney's real autograph?	30	Oct 12, 2015 Reply by Steve Petts
"This is a terrible, pathetic forgery." Edward Siebert replied Oct 8, 2015 to Beatle George Signed Photo Selling as Genuine	4	Oct 8, 2015 Reply by Edward Siebert
"Nope, this is not real." Edward Siebert replied Oct 5, 2015 to John Lennon signed.	2	Oct 5, 2015 Reply by Edward Siebert