Robin McKay's Discussions (718)

Search Forum

View

Discussions Replied To (623) Replies Latest Activity

"My gut instinct was OK when I first saw it. Therefore, I'm going with the gut. From…"

Robin McKay replied Dec 22, 2011 to Paul McCartney Authentic?

 41 Jan 3, 2012
Reply by Anne Marie LaProvidenza

"Cheers MeanMrMustard! As said, once xmas is over and done with, time to get the item…"

Robin McKay replied Dec 22, 2011 to Paul McCartney Authentic?

 41 Jan 3, 2012
Reply by Anne Marie LaProvidenza

"Thanks - its one of my autographs I desperately wanted to be real. All that needs to…"

Robin McKay replied Dec 22, 2011 to Paul McCartney Authentic?

 41 Jan 3, 2012
Reply by Anne Marie LaProvidenza

"Sorry but this looks all wrong to me - having seen signature specimens of his autogr…"

Robin McKay replied Dec 22, 2011 to John lennon authentic?

 53 Apr 30, 2015
Reply by Dave Stein

"I'm with you - looking at specimens, not too sure. If I had to say for definite, I w…"

Robin McKay replied Dec 22, 2011 to Opinions on Johnny Cash signature

 1 Dec 23, 2011
Reply by just some dude

"Yeah Ebay is rife with dodgy things but then again, its so open as well which means…"

Robin McKay replied Dec 22, 2011 to "Beatles" on eBay

 5 Dec 22, 2011
Reply by Robin McKay

"I'd let you know if I could see them but I can't but ebay is, in my opinion only, a…"

Robin McKay replied Dec 22, 2011 to "Beatles" on eBay

 5 Dec 22, 2011
Reply by Robin McKay

"Out of interest, where did you get these from Anne Marie? Its a great shame about th…"

Robin McKay replied Dec 22, 2011 to Paul McCartney Authentic?

 41 Jan 3, 2012
Reply by Anne Marie LaProvidenza

"Sorry but I don't trust them either - the style of the signature isn't right. If you…"

Robin McKay replied Dec 22, 2011 to Paul McCartney Authentic?

 41 Jan 3, 2012
Reply by Anne Marie LaProvidenza

"Its ALL just plain wrong."

Robin McKay replied Dec 22, 2011 to Beatles real or fake???

 22 Jan 26, 2012
Reply by DB

RSS

© 2025   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service