I have not seen the S look like that with the big round loop at the top and bottom.
The S was exactly my concern but I feel like everything else looked good. I found 3 other PSA or JSA examples with a round loop at the top, which isn't a lot compared to hundreds of other examples that have more of a flat loop at the top. For the right price, I'm going to add it to my collection. Other than the S, its a beautiful signature. Thanks guy's!