"Do you know if the photo is available for sale? I feel funny asking but it's a nice one."

"+1 I've been wondering why there has been so few responses to this."

"Hi ac1 This thread seems in danger of dying a death before getting any substantial response. Do you want to try posting it in the Beatles category? Worth a try... I'm still on the sceptical side of the fence but I wouldn't want you to…"

"This is true. I do not know these sigs but a good friend of mine has met him, been photographed with him and now they exchange letters a few times a year."

"Surprising, but good to know. Thanks for sharing!"

"Steve - Elton doesn’t reply to all his mail, but there are exceptions. These are his and not secretarial signatures for sure."

"Really? Hard to believe a star as big as Elton John responds to mail requests. He must get hundreds a week minimum. I'm having flashbacks to Charlton Heston... :-) "

"Looks perfect to me - and on an McCartney Productions Ltd post card. He normally sent these out for charity requests. "

"When I read Alf Weavers the original rock and roll bodyguard I discovered that he signed a lot of their signatures. Anything on a flyer is suspect, the more genuine items are on scraps of paper, whatever a fan might have on them if they managed to…"

"They are all real, 100%."

"All four are in the hand of Neil Aspinall."

"Hi Eva, agree re Yoko and same hand. I don't know either re price, but now but when you search the auction under closed it says it says it sold for $850?"

"John still was doing the doodles and looks like he has signed for Ono."

"I tend to agree with Eric. The Lennon "from" and the "Yoko" look particularly similar. I'm not enough of an expert to really give an opinion on the Lennon. I guess you could be lucky and he also signed for Yoko. Was he still…"