The first one is from 2002. I paid it for $350 The second is from the Virgin Megastore event. Compared to other identical autographs, the characteristics are consistent.
I really hate to say it but I'm sure that neither of them are real.
The CD: MJ didn't wrap the beginning and ends of strokes. Most prominently, the beginning of the J should start with a downstroke only, not that little uptick.
The other one is pretty far off overall. A big telltale is that the curved side of the 'h' vertical is on the left on yours. MJ's are always straight on the left except when both sides are curved.