Authenticity is Everything
Stan Lee and Todd McFarlane autographed comic book. Are these real? The first Stan Lee that I bought from the same seller came back as fake from JSA. Sorry for the sideways picture
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Gino DiPrima on
-
-
-
-
Permalink Reply by Eric Keith Longo on
-
Wait, these are all along with the other 3 in the other post from this same source or two? This, whatever it is, has at least some sort of contrast. But is it authentic? If so, it is a good example?
If a different source, again show what I asked for in the other thread: the cert, source, sales pitch, policies, recourse, cost etc.
And when did you purchase?.
-
-
Thanks for the quick response. Yes, same seller. Bought in some Facebook messenger auctions that I participate in (as a buyer and seller). I will upload the COA's when I get home from work. These books cost me about $150 each. I will upload pics of the one that got rejected by JSA as well
-
-
These were all purchased in the last 6 months
-
-
Most welcome. You saw my other response in the other thread?
And the certs, etc? Please post them as mentioned in the other emails.
-
-
-
-
Thank you. I find that irrelevant. Listen to Findbooks (IIRC) in in the other thread who echoed my own objections. Rejected out of hand based on placement, contrast etc. AKA poor examples.
-
-
Yes sir. I appreciate it
-
-
Here is the COA that was issued with this book. The seller is a comic book artist and if the bids gets high enough, he will include custom sketches with the books that he is auctioning. I have several and he is absolutely legitimate, as an artist. He has a large collection of signed books that he says he would get signed at comic book conventions back in the day and being in the business, most were done at no cost to him.
Obviously, my concerns stem from the rejected autograph but once I got the two books side by side, I noticed that the transition from the letter E to the underline looks A typical to any other examples that I could find in searches. On these 2 books autographs, the return from the E to the underline is curved and all others that I have seen have a very sharp transition that comes to a point. Thanks again for helping me with this
-
-
That is a reasonable observation. You are most welcome. Today is my 56th birthday but I made time for you. Waiting.
As I have always said, "even if real, it it is of QUALITY?"
© 2025 Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.
Powered by
Badges | Report an Issue | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
