We are an eBay affiliate and may be compensated for clicks on links that result in purchases.
Authenticity is Everything
AFTAL Steering Committee Statement on Michael Jackson Autographs
The much awaited meeting of the new temporary AFTAL steering committee took place in Coventry on the 3rd January 2013 with the primary objective of addressing the much written about subject of Michael Jackson autographs. The committee is made up of 7 people, 2 of which are not AFTAL dealers. The former board members which included Dominic Manning stood down in order that Garry King and a new committee could then look at things afresh in an effort to resolve the ongoing problem. This new committee has been given free reign to look into and resolve the situation, and is totally free to decide how AFTAL shall move forward.
These alleged fake Michael Jackson signed items were first spotted by some people on a US forum, and quickly linked to Dominic Manning of Behind the Scenes. It was alleged that Dominic had sold hundreds of these to UK dealers via the AFTAL network. It was also suggested that Dominic had sold them as ‘in person’ signatures shortly after MJ’s passing, and had possibly sold hundreds.
It was also quickly established that the MJ’s in question had in fact been mainly purchased from another collector, Adrian Longden, who is well known amongst some US and UK in person collectors.
Adrian is not now, and never has been an AFTAL dealer, so we have very little control over whether he helps out in this matter or not, but we can confirm that he was willing to make a statement for us and spent time being interviewed by well known solicitor advocate Magnus Boyd at his London office.
After a great deal of discussion between all parties, it transpired that Adrian claimed to have obtained around 350 signed images/CD and LP covers during time spent mainly in LA.
Adrian was happy to discuss this with Magnus Boyd who AFTAL employed to both consider action because of the possible libellous accusations being made against AFTAL and its dealers, and in an effort to get an independent opinion of Adrian’s story.
Magnus Boyd confirmed to us that Adrian had confirmed to him via his witness statement that he spent a lot of time in the USA obtaining autographs, and that he believed the MJ items amounted to around 350 in total but that he did not get all of these himself in person, but rather used others, or the items were handed in to staff to be signed and collected later.
These collected items he then sold directly to various dealers and collectors both in the USA and the UK.
Adrian has given us what he considers to be an accurate breakdown of the items he sold and Magnus also considers that in his opinion his statement was both honest and truthful. Magnus also states “by putting this information in a witness statement and signing a statement of truth he was placing himself in a position where, if that statement was used in any subsequent court proceedings and Adrian was found to have been dishonest, he would be in contempt of court. Adrian’s awareness of this last point led him to take considerable care to ensure his statement was accurate.”
We still need to get accurate figures from Dominic Manning as to the number he sold here in the UK, but we expect to have this soon. We are also unsure of the exact number that Dominic obtained in person either here or in the USA, but so far it seems the number will be less than 15.
Whilst we all were very much aware that only one definitive answer and decision was only ever going to be popular and acceptable, we all went into the meeting with a totally open mind, determined to bring this matter to a conclusion, as there are many other matters also requiring our attention.
We began by viewing all the M.J. stock I ( Ken Mills ) had purchased directly from Adrian Longden, items Garry King had obtained from Dominic Manning and countless other examples of known 100% genuine ones including one I obtained myself personally in the late 1990's.
We also had quite a number of examples of MJ autographs which Roger Epperson had authenticated for R & R plus many other examples from other sources, all of which we had been very careful to include.
On viewing these many examples it was clear there were at least two variations of Michael's signature where the 'J' in Jackson either came down in more or less a straight line, or where he continued the line round into a looped 'J'.
On viewing known genuine examples it appears that both variations were used by him at different times. Some of the signed photos we have compared favourably with ones authenticated by Roger, and out of 20 examples only 2 did not make a decent match. We came to the conclusion on the day, that despite our vast combined knowledge it was almost impossible to split the autographs into two separate piles of 'genuine' and 'fake'.
Each time we thought we could see some light at the end of the tunnel someone would then point out something else that could then change our view.
Garry King had made a suggestion shortly after all this started, that it was a well documented medical fact that the use of certain drugs could affect that way in which you sign your name, and with the amounts and types of medication Michael was taking at that time this certainly seems feasible. But that suggestion was not accepted in certain quarters too well, but as we all know, if drink can affect you’re driving and certainly your handwriting then why not drugs? Surely this is something that should be considered?
Jason Thanos who is widely regarded as one of the top and most trusted In Person collectors worldwide, then suggested we view the backs of the photos to see if there was anything that might help us including dates, print numbers etc.This only showed us a letter in the corner of some which suggests they were ones taken into the house and other places. Some had the letter 'A' for Adrian in the top corners, which does suggest that those items were possibly the ones that had been taken into a house or elsewhere to be signed and then returned later, although what we don't know is 'who actually signed them behind closed doors'.
This tends to confirm that certain items were handed into the house Michael Jackson was using, or a member of his entourage took them in to be signed and then handed back later. It is possible that these items were then signed by another hand and therefore not obtained ‘ In Person ‘ and should not have been offered for sale as such.
It has been long established that certain stars have used a secretary for signing their fan-mail etc although this has not been widely discussed before in respect of Michael Jackson, but is this what was happening ?
If anyone in the U.S. can assist us with a possible contact either at Michael's Estate or who would be likely to help shed some light on Michael's signing habits during his last few months then please let me know and I will contact them.
Our conclusion was that it would be wrong to come to any decision on that day as we obviously needed both more time and more evidence, and we are currently making every effort to do this.
We viewed the infamous DVD which is in no way conclusive and is more of a film record of collectors specifically chasing Michael Jackson for autographs.
It does however prove beyond all doubt that Adrian Longden was in Los Angeles during the 3 month period before MJ's death, and had dialogue on a one to one basis with both MJ and his entourage as did a number of other collectors.
The numbers obtained during that period and how they were obtained became the subject of our next investigation and many AFTAL Dealers were phoned in an attempt to get numbers purchased and from where so we could more accurately examine the scale.
The DVD showed us that due to Michael's generous nature, on a number of occasions as many as 20/30 items were taken into various locations at Michael's request and brought out later with a signature on them. This confirms that there is a distinct possibility that those items were not signed by M.J. himself but by someone on his behalf.
In addition, an article in the Autograph Collector Magazine (Jan 2010) confirmed that he had become a very generous signer. “Jackson was always a generous signer and probably signed well over 100,000 autographs over his career, but in the last months of his life he took it to a new level”. “He was signing like a madman in L.A. and Las Vegas since October,” Epperson said. “If you caught him leaving tour rehearsals at Staples Center you could hand him 50 things and he’d sign them all.”
A professional collector reported, “It was the best kept secret among the pros. They really exploited the guy. Some got hundreds of items signed. They’re selling them now for $1,000-$2,000 each.
“Jackson was a sweetheart. You could knock on his limo window and hand things to his driver and Jackson would sign them in the car. These guys were handing him boxes of stuff.”
All of that of course only goes to prove that MJ did indeed sign many hundreds of items in the months leading up to his death contrary to what many had said on the forums, and we have had this confirmed by a number of other people, who have also confirmed that Adrian as well as others obtained considerable numbers of signed M.J. items during this time.
If anyone else has any categoric evidence to prove that Adrian Longden or anyone else known to him might have faked MJ's autograph, and is prepared to come forward and enlighten us, then we will be very pleased to hear from them. But in the meantime we can only surmise that the quantity that seems to be involved was more than possible to obtain.
In conclusion, we all had roughly a 500 mile round trip and spent a good 7 hours in total viewing and discussing this matter. We all felt that as a group we are neither qualified enough, nor have enough information at this time to make the decision most people had hoped for. We have listed many things we still need to do in order to continue our investigations, and have already made a start on these.
Anyone who thinks we have tried to cover up any matter relating to this investigation is perfectly entitled to their opinion, but I can assure you they could not be more wrong.
In a lot of ways it was frustrating not to have left the meeting with any solid conclusion, but all of those on the committee now know that it isn't quite as cut and dried as a lot of people had imagined.
Further meetings and investigations will continue in order to try and arrive at the truth, and we will of course keep everyone informed as and when we have something to report. I would reiterate that if anyone has any information not previously reported or supplied then we would all be glad to hear from you and your information will be dealt with in the strictest of confidence.
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Rick Meyer on
-
Sorry Bob but that is exactly what I believe. I think the majority of you were picked by AFTAL for a reason. I think AFTAL either considered you "yes" men, friends of board directors or folks that wouldn't buck the trend.
I hope I'm a million light years from the truth. So far I've seen nothing that indicates that I'm wrong.
-
Permalink Reply by Robert McCluskey on
-
Well, you can believe what you like, that's your right. Speaking for myself I would never have got involved in this in the first place had I thought I would be here at 3am on a Monday morning having questions asked about my own integrity, never in a lifetime.
I don't have legal cover to risk any kind of civil case against myself, but I have never been an AFTAL dealer, I have never met Dominic or Adrian, nor have I ever purchased anything from either of them. I have no connection to either of them or any reason to want to either protect them or denegrade them
See how today pans out when others join in, but I'm hitting the sack now and may say something without thinking that lands me in deep water !
-
Permalink Reply by Jason Thanos on
-
I have no internet am using my Iphone I have not even read whats been said yet except that you think people were hand picked . Actualy dissappimted with most of you myself and the others who have taken this shite job so we can help the people are now been slagged and accused . Let be known we are not allowed to talk and not our choise . Now if this dont tell you the truth rick , brandon and all the rest of you then am sorry to say you will never get the point .
We Resigned by our own RESIGNED our names are no longer on the official site !!!
Let me ask you smart guys when does one decide to resign ? People who between them poasibly have led the war against fakes in the UK for years and have the respect of the world !!!
Sorry guys I was hopping if you guys stood back and looked properly you will get it but it seems no one cares about the truth . I hope some of you out there eventually realise the true facts and not some made up b******* that I and the other did anything but worked our socks off not only for free but even wasted money from our own pockets to pay for trips to meetings petrol , Tine thousands of emails , phone calls and phone bills all we paid for who ? For what ? And to hear that this group that did all this suddenly betrayes you . Dissapointed please next time try to get the facts guys .
-
-
I have the same qiuestions. I'm following it the same way Carl. Amazing.
I think some of these guys were hand picked so as not to buck the trend.
-
Permalink Reply by Rich on
-
Wow, I leave to watch the Super Bowl and this thing explodes . . .
Looks like the logical next step isn't a cleanup effort, but putting certain people in jail, where they belong. These guys decidedly made a small fortune selling forged garbage, got caught and now can only respond by threatening people. Time to find a new career.
-
Permalink Reply by Ken Mills on
-
I think some of these guys were hand picked so as not to buck the trend.
What an absolute crock of sh--e! Let he who is without sin ?????????
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BxeFMHyOx3I
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KiIP_KDQmXs
You guys are so full of double standards it's mindblowing.
P.S :- Those clips are for anyone with a sense of humour - don't see too many about on here.
-
Permalink Reply by Steve Cyrkin, Admin on
-
Rick,
You are way off-track. Yes men were the last thing the steering committee was.
I had a late night and just got home, but will tell you what I know shortly.
-
Permalink Reply by Markus Brandes on
-
Dear Autograph Enthusiast
AFTAL was a good organization which I enjoyed to be part of. Most certainly there had been a reason why the ACAF lists of recommended dealers missed some names which had been proudly recommended by AFTAL. My highly respected and very knowledge friend Rolf Ramseier never joined AFTAL and there was a reason for that.Autograph friends.... PLEASE.... always ask yourself if offers look to be good to be true, particularly if collectors offer in quantity. Here are people involved who get a reputation not by the quality of their items but their afford they did for an organization.
It is always your choice what you trust or what you like to trust. Please be always careful particular with big contemporary names and if there is the smallest doubt pass and be patient until you get the real deal. Back up your thoughts by other knowledge people and I personally highly respect Roger Epperson's and Rolf Ramseier's opinions, which are both - helpful and knowledgeable!
Unfortunately the only solution to the current situation for myself is to have canceled my AFTAL membership although many good and trustful people previously had been part of it.
Now I just pray that the possible fraud does alert collectors and they do their own homework before they spend much money for a previously what seems to be bargain but has no value......
-
Permalink Reply by Brandon Mysinger on
-
For MONTHS, I was attacked for my personal opinions regarding AFTAL. Even though my east, TN common sense was telling me that the original organization had truly twisted itself into a fraud ring. I asked serious questions out of its members an in return, I would get attacked from people who were determined to protect the people who were running the club. That's fine, I'm just glad to know that my instincts were right. Heck, I was hoping this new committee was going to prove me wrong since I trusted a couple if the members of the steering committee.
I know that the "steering committee" were not picked because they could protect Domenic Manning, Garry King, Adrian Longstreet, or whoever ends up being the group of fraudsters. The whole steering committee was truly just a diversion. A diversion created in hopes of shutting people up and buying time for the few crooks who needed to protect themselves.
I will never divulge my sources. However, a very small % of us on this site were right about AFTAL. We took a lot of heat from certain people on this site. The point is, now we know. I'm sure that the police will sort it all out in time. Thankfully though, the news is finally out. Who knows how long it would have taken to be told had a few brave friends had not contacted me.
-
-
Brandon - AFTAL has (or had) around 150 dealers. The problems are with perhaps a handful of those dealers. To suggest the organisation is one big fraud ring is wholly inacurate and unfair to the many good folk who work their tatas off fighting fakers on a daily basis.
I don't think anyone will try and defend individual members (who can and should defend themselves, to be honest), but you are wording your statements to hit out at every single dealer involved in AFTAL when we are not even talking a majority, not even 10% - not even 5% of the dealers ! And whilst we all agree that 5% is too many, hitting 95% with a charge of being party to a fraud ring is grossly unfair - especially when a number of them have resigned since this issue was raised.
I'm not an apologist for AFTAL, or a member, but as a full time, professional dealer who has put more hours into fighting fakers than most I think it is wrong to demonise a whole group through the actions of a handful.
-
-
Someone who is wayyyy smarter than me reminded me that Dominic Manning "stepped aside", he NEVER "stepped down". It seems that there was at least one vein of the "old" AFTAL which was trying to dominate and control the "new" steering committee.
Had certain people not reached out beyond the "leadership" of the old AFTAL, we would have NEVER gotten the whole story.
I have questioned why this "new" steering committee didn't speak out against the B.S. evidence. Each and every one of them knows that the items in question are bad. This passive / liberal "lets give them time" crap went on way too long. Kiss my Conservative butt! The people in "power" should have done what is right way back when Adrian's material was found to be forgeries.
However, at least people now know a bit more about the AFTAL "leadership"( not talking about the NEW steering committee members who were brought in) the people who had the most to lose were clinging to hope that the new members would save them.
Now, we will have a "theives fall-out". The people who are the main crooks behind the ordeal will turn on each other. As always!
Blog Posts
Ebay Seller Smpsportscards Sells Forged Counterfeit Willie Mays 1996-97 Topps Autograph Card
Posted by CJCollector on November 11, 2024 at 6:03pm 0 Comments 1 Like
COA CSA Authentic Forged Babe Ruth Cut Autograph Laughable
Posted by CJCollector on November 9, 2024 at 2:32pm 7 Comments 0 Likes
Ebay Seller Tsuch67 Sells Forged Mickey Mantle Duke Snider Willie Mays Baseball
Posted by CJCollector on October 30, 2024 at 3:13pm 2 Comments 0 Likes
Photos
© 2024 Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.
Powered by
Badges | Report an Issue | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
