Hello everyone,

I mainly collect guitarists, and do alot of searching on ebay for certain players. I already have both The Edge and Ronnie Wood, but am always looking for others to add to my collection. And it was while searching for the generic "guitarist signed" on ebay that i found several items i would like to get your opinions on. They are stickered already by a third party, GA, but i would still like opinions. 

My personal opinion is that The Edge signature looks somewhat off, although i am not that great on U2 signatures. The shaping doesnt seem exatly right, and the tornado underneath i typically see in a different area. But this signature could be totally authentic, and if it is, i might purchase. Any opinions?

The next is a Ronnie Wood that to me also doesnt look right. The Ronnie is the part that concerns me the most, but it could also be totally authentic. The Wood portion is easily forged, and Ronnie often does it all in one stroke, so i cant say much their. But the first name formation has me concerned. Any opinions? If real, this is also an autograph i would consider purchasing for a fair price, as its a very nice picture.

Thank you for all your help and for viewing

Carl