Hi, a relative of mine purchased a Babe Ruth autograph recently and I was hopeful that some of you could shed light on its authenticity.

The autograph is in pencil on a program from the 1940s golden gloves boxing tournament in NYC. I found a newspaper article saying he attended the 1939 one, but have been unable to find anything regarding 1940. Picture below, thanks:

https://imgur.com/a/66Nne2g

Views: 275

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I’m inclined to think this is real, but check with more knowledgeable members like Terrier, Christopher Williams, and Randy.

Thank you, I will check in with them

Glad they chimed in!

I have to be honest, I rarely opine on Ruth signatures because there are so many well executed forgeries out there.  But I see a lot of issues with this example.  

Thank you for the reply! I'd love to know some of the issues if you have the time to write any out. I can see why there would be skepticism and am not denying it could be fake but would like to figure out why if possible.

both B's are atypical in my opinion, as is the unusual finishing stroke of the "e".  The R is off and the t has an unusual right tilt to it.  The entire signature looks off to me.

Totally fair, thank you for the reply once again. I did find other examples of matching "pointed" Rs but the other concerns are highly valid. My hope is he signed this hurriedly in the crowd at the event but that maybe wishful thinking.

entirely possible, but not having witnessed it, we are left with judging the signature as presented.  

Such is the problem with autograph collecting! Thanks again for your time.

Back then the crowds for autographs were not like they are today. People didn’t push and shove nor did they yell at celebrities like they do today. Those are not autograph collectors doing that. It’s the dealers and those who sell. Most autographs seekers back then were respectful and patiently waited their turns. Was a different era.

Hi Ben,

I'm with Terrier on the Babe Ruth, unfortunately. In my opinion I don't think that there is even a slim chance that Ruth signed it. If your relative paid by credit card or PayPal in the last six months he has a decent chance of getting a refund. Even if he's beyond the return privilege or it's an auction, he still has a chance of getting his money back. 

Was this bought at an estate sale?

Thank you Steve. I believe it was purchased at an estate sale containing mostly boxing memorabilia, so the Ruth seemed unusual in the bunch. I'll alert them to this thread so they can see what you've all said on the matter. I really do appreciate the additional opinions you've given me, they're very helpful especially going forward.

RSS

PRIVATE SIGNINGS

Official Pix is offering a near complete Vacation cast signing with Chevy Chase, Beverly D’Angelo, Dana Barron & Randy Quaid, with Personalization, Character Name & Quote options! The order deadline for Chevy Chase is this Monday, Jan. 14. Send-Ins need to arrive by Jan. 16. The other signings will be in February & March. Go to www.OfficialPix.com now to see over 130 different photos & posters to choose from—or send your items in now!

Premier Collectibles, America's Largest Autographed Bookstore, is holding a Live Video Book Signing with Jackie Chan of the Hardcover Collectors Edition of his Book, Never Grow Up, on January 22 at 7PM ET. You can watch it live and ask a question that Jackie can answer during the signing. If you're a Jackie Chan fan you won't want to miss this!

STEINER SPORTS has relationships with thousands of athletes spanning every major sport. We bridge the gap between you and your favorite athletes. Want your ticket autographed by Stephen Curry? No problem. A personalized "Happy Birthday" photograph from Kristaps Porzingis? That can be arranged, too. See all the signings coming up between now and March 31 at Steiner Sports.com

Fanatics Authentic has exclusive autograph relationships with many of the biggest sports stars. We strive to bring you truly unique items and the highest quality collectibles on the market today. All of our exclusive player autographs are witnessed by a Fanatics Authentic Representative, ensuring that you receive a 100% genuine signature. View our entire roster of stars in all major sports at www.fanaticsauthentic.com/pages/Exclusive_Athletes.

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2019   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Community Manager.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service