Authenticity is Everything
Is the eBay seller LIVINGTHEDREAMAUTOGRAPHS legit?
Hi everyone,
I’m looking at buying a signed photo from an eBay seller called LIVINGTHEDREAMAUTOGRAPHS, and I wanted to ask if anyone here has experience in buying from the seller. The seller claims to have a good reputation and photo proof in meeting the celebrities but not the celebrities signing the actual item.
From what I can see, the seller has 100% positive feedback and thousands of items sold, and the store has been around for several years. The seller says the autographs come from conventions and personal signings. (eBay)
However, I know autographs on eBay can be risky, so I wanted to check with the community first.
Has anyone here bought from this seller before?
Did the autograph pass PSA/DNA, JSA, BAS, or another authentication service?
Any red flags I should know about? Should I proceed with caution?
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Eric Keith Longo
-
Can you show the photo?
-
Permalink Reply by Ahmad Ghazy
-
-
Can you just post the image here? Try this.
-
-
-
Permalink Reply by Steve Cyrkin, Admin
-
If a signed item passed PSA/DNA, JAS, BAS, or another respected authenticator, the seller would have said that. They also would post the COA if it has one and state its COA number, post the TPA's sticker on the item, and commonly link to the item in the TPA's database.
-
-
I thought OP meant did anyone ever submit anything they purchased raw from this seller. It seems to be all very modern stuff I am not familiar with.
-
-
I wanted to obtain this autograph.
-
-
I'm glad you came here. Neither Shia's nor Megan's autographs are real IMO. This is a real Shia LaBeouf. Study the way it's signed, and the energy. The one you posted bears a basic resemblance to his real autograph, but that's it.
These are both Megan's and Shia's genuine autographs authenticated by BAS, The script looks like a reprint to me, but I may be wrong:
I image searched the photo you posted and found the eBay seller. He claims that his son is a well-known and well-respected in-person professional collector. He supposedly goes to all the ComiCons and most of the other major conventions.
Almost all of the autographs they offer are on index cards—but IP collectors virtually always want photos signed, because that's what fans and collectors want. Popular celeb autographs on signed photos are generally worth many times what they're worth on index cards. Why would he get them signed on cards?
I reviewed 20+ of this seller's signed listings on index cards, and they all looked like they were signed by the same 1 or 2 people IMO—not the celebs.
Sign up for our Newsletter!
Photos
© 2026 Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.
Powered by
Badges | Report an Issue | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
