We're an eBay affiliate and may be compensated on purchases made through clicks.
This is from the current Gotta Have Rock and Roll auction. It comes with an LOA from JSA, but I see problems with all three signatures. The current bid is $12.5K with the buyer’s premium. What do you think?
It does seem perhaps odd that all sigs are in dark areas when they didn't have to be, but I imagine you have some other observation :-)
Indeed, signed with attention to contrast. Other than that - I would not know. I am curious what you have spotted!
The presentation, spatial relationships and baseline look haphazard in comparison. Hopefully, keen eyes collectors will see that and the "couldn't be much worse" contrast and pass.
The only thing that doesn't seem haphazard is the placement.