We are an eBay affiliate and may be compensated for clicks on links that result in purchases.

http://www.rrauction.com/bidtracker_detail.cfm?IN=952

Come on Roger, I hope you hadn't seen this one yet. I mean the Richard is pretty good for a fake but the other 3 are very bad. And you tell me who would have the opportunity to get 4 members of Pink Floyd in a white paint pen. This is laughable.


Moderator's Note: Most members think the signed album is genuine. We have not deleted or altered the posting member's opening or replies, but we did rewrite the title to remove Jim Officer's claim from it that the album was fake.

Views: 5573

Attachments: No photo uploads here

Replies are closed for this discussion.

Replies to This Discussion

YOUR PROBLY TALKING ABOUT JUSTIN MASER HE IS ONE OF THE BIGGEST FORGERS IN THE UNIVERSE AND PINK FLOYD IS ONE OF HIS FAVES TO DO. WHEN I LIVED IN SEATTLE HE WOULD ALWAYS NOT GET THE PEOPLE AND THEN HE WOULD HAVE THEM ON EBAY 6 MONTHS LATER. EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THE COLLECTORS KNOW HE IS A FORGER AND TALK ABOUT HIM BEHIND HIS BACK, BUT THEY NEVER CALL HIM OUT. GLAD I DON'T LIVE THERE ANYMORE.

ROGER WAS REAL NICE WHEN I GOT HIM AND PERSONALIZED EVERYBODYS STUFF WITH A GOLD PAINT PEN. HE DONT DO PHOTO-OPS THOUGH. THAT ALBUM KIND OF LOOKS LIKE HIS AUTOGRAPH AND IT KINDA DOESTN TOO.

Hi.

I have just joined this site and thought I would make a contribution. I own a "The Wall" signed CD cover, it is signed by David, Richard and Nick. signed in 2009 shortly before Richards death, it was donated by the band to Bonhams ( leading London auction house) to raise money for a childrens charity. David and Nick have signed with a black pen and Richard has signed in silver. In September Roger Waters is playing in Manchester (UK) and I have arranged for Jason Thanos (who will be graphing Roger) to take this item with him and have Roger complete the set. I just thought you may like to see it and would like to ask what you think its value would be when complete. Incidentally, the lots that were sold at the auction are still available online for viewing, this item was sold with a seperate signed photo that I do not own.

http://www.bonhams.com/auctions/16905/lot/225/?page_anchor=r1%3D404...

Dave.

[URL=http://s880.photobucket.com/user/codder1/media/TheWallsigned001.jpg.html][IMG]http://i880.photobucket.com/albums/ac1/codder1/TheWallsigned001.jpg[/IMG][/URL]

Both fine AUTHENTIC examples. Very nice items.

I would like to know the story of this item. Roger Waters signs like that during recent years... his "rushed on tour" autograph. :) Others - I dont see anything wrong there.

Unfortunatelly I don't get that information when I authenticate for an auction house.  They may have the information and if they do I'm sure they would pass it along to you.  Again, there is nothing wrong with this album.

Other then it's fake, and everyone need to question your judgement or consider you are the one behind them. This is a bad day when Roger Epperson can't spot such obvious fakes.

Or I'm behind them, what are trying to say?

I am saying Roger you are sitting here with you balls in the wind calling a circle a square! Either you have completely lost it, never had it, or you are behind it.

I'm sure I never had it...you da man!

It's amazing the way children act now days.  My dad would have beat me silly if I talked to someone as respected as me like this.

lol, too funny man. I can dig miles up miles of dirt on you bro, don't sit here an tell me I, or anyone owes you damn thing. The problem with you authenticators is you can never just admit when you are wrong. You keep moving the issue away and never explain anything. duhhhh "I think they are real", what a joke. Nice analysis expert. Hey everyone, the sun is brown!!! I know it look yellow to you but since you have never been there you don't know what you are talking about. What a joke.

I was reading this thread with great interest until I read Mr. Officer write "I can dig miles and miles of dirt on you."

Why? 

Roger's must be a god on this site, geeze. Just google the guys name and some have painted an ugly story. But like I said in another discussion about him is that people make mistakes, and he admits them and owns up from what I read. Unlike PSA who never admits fault for example. I only wrote that to point out to all his rescuers that the guy is not perfect. He has made many mistakes and nobody should trust him blindly. Not that he is defrauding people, but because he is human and he makes mistakes like every authenticator.

RSS

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2024   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service