We're an eBay affiliate and may be compensated on purchases made through clicks. 

 

This CSN (Crosby card) is scertfied real by PSA--in my opinion BOTH the NASh and Stills are poor forgeries. Look at this photo---there is no way nash or Stills signed it. I cant comment on the Corsby card as I put up a signed book here last week and no one said yes or no--i still feel that one is good---but PSA is wrong---this is a forgery of the NAS hand STILLS!

 

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Crosby-Stills-Nash-Signed-8x10-Photo-and-In...

 

 

This below IMO is a real crosby graph...different seller.. anyone agree with my analysis of the crosby below and the forgery above on the NASH STILLS...?

 

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Crosby-Stills-Nash-Signed-8x10-Photo-and-In...

Tags: CSN, Crosby, nash, stills

Views: 1918

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I've mentioned here before that I know the guy who is Press Pass Collectibles (Kyle Bell) and he is a known forger in the Phoenix area. He was buddies with Mike Aring. He used to brag about using auto pen a few years back.

Intersting....thanks--because he is selling some extremely high end and high priced items right now---double beck guitar signed by led Zep, Pinkj floyd electric guitar by 3 of 4, Stones guitar by all 5..so I guess buyer bweare again. OTPOH--this specific CSN album I gave the link to he has for sale--IS real---it's not a high end item signed by just nash/ Stills... he also has a GNR (MANY GNR_ signed guitars for sale...have to be careful those AXL graphs are REAL lol Thanks for the heads up!

Here are images from your eBay link (click to enlarge...they're big):

David,

You know, I think you're probably right. The Stills is bugging me more and more now too. I should have compared them more closely.

Thanks...today's lesson learned.

Steve..and THAT is why I hate PSA lol...they gave this th photo the OK (that Crosby signed CARD MAY be real--maybe that threw them off!)   OK..but  they denied REAL CSN albums I showed them! Albums  I SAW sigend by all  in front of me...very strange .... yeah but that Stephen Stills on that 8x10 is wrong---it's a bad 8x10..I dont know why someone would fake them---Stills and nash are fine gentleman and will sign when asked politely. But PSA missed the mark here.

IN closer examination--I think the CROSBY PSA Card is probably REAL (95% chance)..that is how he signs when he doesnt write "david" just D Crosby in recent years (looks like a 2005 or 2006 era sig)....so we have a good Crosby card and BAD nash.Stills ..now thats strange..usually the other way around lol.

Check out the scans I am putting up of several iconic albums..I am nost interested in opinion on the STYX lp--scans should be up in 1 minute..I am 99% sure the other items are real..(well I saw some signed)..others..jus twant verification for my sleep. TAG--THE WALL PINK FLOYD

Just had a quick question, why are you asking about the authenticity of items  you saw signed yourself ?

I didnt see them all signed. I wrote I am 99% sure the other items are real--but id NO tsee them all signed..   iwant verification on those. I did NOt see  most of the items U just put up signed  such as the STYX lp, the Chapin nor did I see the Foreinger signed, nor The who--but I am sure the Who is real..just want verification. 

I was just thrown off when you said in your reply " I am 99 percent sure the other items are real....well i saw some signedj,, just wanted verification for my sleep".

Ok i worded it a bit off--true...just because I think 99% the items I did not see signed are god--I still always have the 1%

Have you considered using JSA for music instead of PSA? The each have their sweetspots. Roger Epperson does most of JSA's better music and he's hard to beat. PSA is a better than JSA on modern Hollywood and music artists who became stars since the 2000s.

new scansi Put up--if yo uc can let me know what you think o nthese..i thin kall real--maybe mot Styx..unsure.  http://live.autographmagazine.com/forum/topics/authenticity-questio...

RSS

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2024   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service