We are an eBay affiliate and may be compensated for clicks on links that result in purchases.

Having been an autograph collector now for many years, let me pass on a few words of wisdom. Ebay has many good and bad autographs. Just because it comes with a COA, even from PSA or JSA, does NOT guarantee authenticity. After all, it is just an opinion. Any so-called expert can make mistake. Unfortunately, for resale value, a PSA COA often helps close the sale. So that is an issue for a potential buyer in the future. But, for the present, GAI, ACE, PAAS, Verified, AMA, and other similar authenticators have poor reputations and are therefore mostly, in my opinion, unreliable.. So stick with PSA, JSA Spense, Beckett, and the other "legit" companies. Add in Epperson at REAL, Perry Cox, Tracks, and a few others for music, At least their COA's are worth something.

So what does a buyer do? Having been ripped off on eBay and other "collector" auctions and websites, here is some simple advice. Do your own research. Ever wonder what PSA does in their authentication process? They have a bunch of exemplars, i.e. signature example samples, and do a side-by-side comparison. Here's an amazing idea; do the same thing. Take the picture off the eBay auction and then go onto the internet and do a Google image search for the signer. Unless it a rare signer, you will get countless John Waynes, Babe Ruths, Paul McCartneys, Neil Armstrongs, and Elvis Presleys, etc., with which to compare. They even often cover several signing decades so you can watch the signature change as the signer ages.

Then you won't have to get a "quick opinion" from PSA or rely on a COA from a company no one has ever heard of. I finally learned my lesson and now do all my own research. No, I am not an expert, but I am more educated about real vs fake and confident to at least eliminate the obvious forgeries. Remember to use a magnifying glass or enlarge the image on your computer monitor do get all the nuances. it makes a difference.

And one more obvious thought. If it's cheap, it's FAKE. A John Wayne autograph for $50 is FAKE. I don't care if the seller's mother got it from him on the set of "The Shootist" because she was his make-up artist. It's a STORY and it's still a FAKE. If it is for sale at a price way below comparable autographs, it's a FAKE. I see Michael Jackson Thriller albums for $150. Really? He will never sign another, so get a clue because it's a FAKE! And please, NEVER buy from anyone without a money-back policy or use PayPal to allow you to reverse the charges in the event you have been taken.

Anyway, thanks for reading this far and you get the gist. Let the buyer beware and do your homework. It's your money. Hey out there. Any further thoughts and other suggestions?

Views: 672

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Some good stuff here, but the notion of googling images to get your exemplars and make side by side comparisons may be flawed and dangerous. I submit that you will find as many fakes as real in some image searches so you will be using bad exemplars.

Reliable authenticators have verified good exemplars and it takes time to build a library. I have about 500 unquestionably real Neil Armstrongs alone and I've been building for over 10 years. I'm not discouraging people from DIYing it, but they need to be careful about the exemplars they use. And in my opinion, just capturing a bunch of images from TPA approved items is not verified exemplars. That is how mistakes repeat themselves.

Fair enough, beware of "bad" exemplars but there are many "good" examples if you weed through them.

I think it's excellent advice. I am a self-taught "expert" on Michael Jackson and Johnny Cash using the same techniques you have outlined here. I've seen certed signs of Jackson that look nothing like the signature I know to be his from ALL the majors, all the time. Now, whether they certed erroneously or someone is making fake COA's I can't say, but my point is obvious. As a sometime seller, with all the disinformation out there, I don't necessarily agree with the advice on return policy though. What's to stop a buyer from claiming fake on buyer's remorse or any number of reasons they might have (including disinformation) to return an item? IMHO, 3PA is unnecessary for any real fan of autographs. They make money because people are lazy, greedy, and afraid of being ripped off - which is a sad state of affairs all the way around. It hurts buyers and sellers when people won't buy without certs, but why should I pay some 3PA when the proof is in the pudding as far as erroneous certs go? Especially when I can and have done my homework! If you have eyes and a brain, do some research and save yourself whatever they charge these days. Wouldn't touch any of them with a ten foot pole, personally.

RSS

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2024   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service