Caitlin H
  • Hazlet, NJ
  • United States
Share on Facebook
Share on Facebook

Caitlin H's Discussions

Mel Allen - Add to Collection or Pass?

Started this discussion. Last reply by Caitlin H May 2. 2 Replies

It's listed as:MEL ALLEN dec. 1996 auto signed 8x10 photo New York…Continue

Shirley Mitchell - I Love Lucy

Started this discussion. Last reply by eddy Apr 28. 9 Replies

My friend is interested in I Love Lucy for a research project and came across two photos of Shirley Mitchell. The JSA one is listed at $120 or best offer while the other has a starting bid at $34. We…Continue

 

Caitlin H's Page

Latest Activity

Caitlin H replied to Caitlin H's discussion Mel Allen - Add to Collection or Pass?
"Thanks for your analysis of the photo in question."
May 2
Peter Izzo replied to Caitlin H's discussion Mel Allen - Add to Collection or Pass?
"This compares favorably to the my personalized auto from Mr Allen. "
Apr 28
eddy replied to Caitlin H's discussion Shirley Mitchell - I Love Lucy
"I see.  Stick with the JSA one."
Apr 28
Caitlin H posted discussions
Apr 28
Caitlin H replied to Caitlin H's discussion Shirley Mitchell - I Love Lucy
"Different sellers."
Apr 28
Eric Keith Longo replied to Caitlin H's discussion Shirley Mitchell - I Love Lucy
"That's what I saw - I'd pass over the $34 one."
Apr 28
eddy replied to Caitlin H's discussion Shirley Mitchell - I Love Lucy
"Are these both from the same seller?  I believe the JSA one is fine.  I'd be hesitant about the other.  She did live a very long life and was apparently good in signing."
Apr 28
Eric Keith Longo replied to Caitlin H's discussion Shirley Mitchell - I Love Lucy
""Your mileage may vary" = some collectors want those stickers (PSA, BAS, JSA, ACOA) and some prefer them on the back. Others prefer them on the certificate, some don't want any sticker at all."
Apr 28
Caitlin H replied to Caitlin H's discussion Shirley Mitchell - I Love Lucy
"Thanks for the advice. I’m not sure what YMMV means."
Apr 28
Eric Keith Longo replied to Caitlin H's discussion Shirley Mitchell - I Love Lucy
"PS - Very wise to ask here before purchase."
Apr 28
Eric Keith Longo replied to Caitlin H's discussion Shirley Mitchell - I Love Lucy
"Multiple Gregory Peck @ $59...caution. I did not look at much."
Apr 28
Eric Keith Longo replied to Caitlin H's discussion Shirley Mitchell - I Love Lucy
"I can't speak to this but seller has Paul Henreid for $44. Butterfly McQueen for $39 as well. I would advise caution. I also am against stickers but YMMV."
Apr 28
Caitlin H is now a member of Autograph Live
Apr 16
Welcome Them!

About Me

What kind of member are you? (Check as many as apply.)
Collector
What would you like to tell us about yourself, your collecting, or business.
I collect 1939 New York World’s Fair photos
What is your level of expertise?
Beginner
Why do you want to join Autograph Live?
To learn interesting facts
Who can we thank for telling you about us?
No one
What are your areas of interest?
Sports, Books/Literature
You can ask anyone living or dead for their autograph. Who would it be?
Lucille Ball
What is today's date?
April 16, 2025

Comment Wall

You need to be a member of Autograph Live to add comments!

Join Autograph Live

  • No comments yet!
 
 
 

© 2025   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service