We are an eBay affiliate and may be compensated for clicks on links that result in purchases.
Tags:
Andreas,
And you have your opinion too, that's great. I have studied the Canadian forgers for years now and in my opinion I do not believe this was done by them.
Hi Andreas,
Welcome to Live! When I approved your membership yesterday, I noticed that you called yourself a beginner. If you're a beginner, why are you so sure it's bad? Can you upload some examples that support your case?
Kevin alone is very careful about authenticity. He guarantees everything for life and I know a collector he gave a refund to a couple years ago on something he sold in the early-1990s.
Hi Steve,
Yes, I consider my self as a beginner. I don't consider myself an expert in anything because I'm simply a collector.
This particular piece was sold on ebay. I started looking for Elvis' autograph in 2006. Since I'm located in Norway I thought Ebay was the only way to find something like this.
The seller went by these seller ids: aztec-rino, sunlady1969, percypurple, bigjake1120, roadshowcarny, sweetcarnation
One thing that made me suspicious was that the seller didn't want payment to go through paypal..
Here are a few examples:
http://julienslive.com/view-auctions/catalog/id/3/lot/208/from/find...
http://julienslive.com/view-auctions/catalog/id/3/lot/238/from/find...
http://www.ebay.com/itm/ELVIS-PRESLEY-SIGNED-AUTOGRAPHED-VINTAGE-LO...
This only goes by memory, and I do remember these being sold on ebay by this seller..
I don't how to that on this site and I'm now home for the weekend.
I am 99% certain this did not sell on Ebay. I have a lot of history on this item that the Canadian's don't offer, even when and where and for whom it was signed for. This next example you show looks absolutely nothing like the poster. The salutation is not close the "E" again is bigger then the "L" and it's a mess. Look at the "Y" on the photo I posted and then the one on the poster, they are near perfect matches. Note the backward slash mark after he finishes the "Y", exact. The Canadians didn't do that. I'm sure I can find many examples of the "P" touching the "R" in my files and I don't work from memory.
The problem here is when you posted you wrote "this CLEARLY is" making it look like you are the end all of all opinions on this signature and that the 5 other people that looked it are nuts. So this gives fuel to Greg's fire that he has caught me making a mistake when in fact I studied this piece very closely on more then one occasion, not from memory but from side by side comparisons to known exemplars. Sorry if I sound a bit harsh but I do defend my opinions as they are VERY educated ones. When you posted your comment Greg jumped on it like a baby kitty on her mommas teet. It's fine to make your own opinion and make a statement but using all cap type is just the same on any blog as getting an all cap email from your boss, it makes a difference.
Roger,
I apologize your using capital letters on that. I can see why this may seem disrespectful. I'm simply sharing my own opinion and from remembering a piece like this that sold on ebay. A friend of mine actually purchased a signed note from this seller. The way the Y is written in Presley is consistent with the latest forgeries I saw from this seller. I thought of taking a screenshot of those auctions, but unfortunately I didn't do that.
Again, I'm sorry if I have written anything that is disrespectful.
No problem, your opinion is welcome here. I'm glad you understand where I'm coming from. Thanks
Roger
Hi Andreas,
Thanks for filling me in--and the examples. Are you saying this exact one, with WWW.CVTREASURES.COM was sold on eBay? Could you point out specifically why you're sure the poster is a forgery?
Thanks
Posted by CJCollector on November 27, 2024 at 2:23pm 0 Comments 1 Like
Posted by CJCollector on November 11, 2024 at 6:03pm 0 Comments 1 Like
Posted by CJCollector on November 9, 2024 at 2:32pm 7 Comments 0 Likes
© 2024 Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin. Powered by
Badges | Report an Issue | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service