Randy's Discussions (816)

Discussions Replied To (779) Replies Latest Activity

"Both authentic IMO."

Randy replied Oct 9, 2014 to Mickey Mantle Autographs. Real?

13 Dec 11, 2014
Reply by Steve Zarelli

"No shot!"

Randy replied Sep 27, 2014 to Think I found an authentic Mickey Mantle!

12 Sep 28, 2014
Reply by CJCollector

"I think it might be authentic but agree with Terrier that we need a clearer picture…"

Randy replied Sep 21, 2014 to Mantle please help

4 Sep 22, 2014
Reply by Joel

"It is authentic."

Randy replied Sep 21, 2014 to Yankee Team Signed Ball

9 Sep 21, 2014
Reply by Randy

"No shot in my opinion. I have never seen an Aaron that looked even close to that one…"

Randy replied Sep 19, 2014 to Any idea about these? Hank Aaron signed baseball(s).

11 Sep 19, 2014
Reply by James

"Much better shot but I still don't think it will pass a legitimate 3rd party service…"

Randy replied Sep 18, 2014 to Ruth cut: Authentic? doubt it.

5 Sep 18, 2014
Reply by terrier8HOF

"Not authentic."

Randy replied Sep 18, 2014 to Ruth cut: Authentic? doubt it.

5 Sep 18, 2014
Reply by terrier8HOF

"Unauthenticated it is worth $250-300 or so to the right collector IMO.   Authenticat…"

Randy replied Sep 16, 2014 to Roger Maris Autograph, Real or Fake?

18 Sep 17, 2014
Reply by Dane

"Exactly."

Randy replied Sep 14, 2014 to Stan Musial Signed ball

51 Jan 27, 2015
Reply by Dom Vito Castiglione

"Stan the Man certificates if original are good. I think Stan may have actually signe…"

Randy replied Sep 13, 2014 to Stan Musial Signed ball

51 Jan 27, 2015
Reply by Dom Vito Castiglione

RSS

© 2025   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service