I have 2 photos already signed by Harold Ramis and a hat signed by Bill Murray that I would love to add Dan onto these items but absolutely do not trust the post office back and forth. 

I contacted Mistych who were super nice and said they would make an exception where I could drop off before the event and pick of my items in person after it was complete. No offense to them personally of course but I have no idea if I should trust a company like this with these high priced items. They also have insurance that can be purchased on top of the autograph price but I see it as a joke. Insurance doesn't guarantee I'll see my items again. 

Overall, I'm scared to put my trust into others with my items. If I do this, I would only pay the fee for 3 signatures, not the extra insurance. Am I wrong second guessing this or should I just go ahead with it and take the chance? I have 1 more month until items are due. 

What would you do?