SeaEls
  • San Ramon, CA
  • United States
Share on Facebook
Share on Facebook

SeaEls's Discussions

Pat Tillman - is it real?

Started Sep 16 0 Replies

I’m suspicious of basically everything despite having a PSA cert  (especially after Brett Lemieux) but this all seems to check out. It’s post 2009 PSA sticker and appears to be a basic cert from the…Continue

Aaron Judge - Fanatics

Started this discussion. Last reply by SeaEls Jun 30, 2025. 17 Replies

Need an educated opinion on this -Got an eBay Aaron Judge with a Fanatics label on it. Hopefully someone has knowledge of Fanatics labels - I don’t have the best opinion of them and know there can be…Continue

Mantle Signed Baseball - Real?

Started this discussion. Last reply by SeaEls Jun 25, 2025. 5 Replies

Need your help! Is this Mantle authentic? It looks good to me but Beckett signature review says unlikely - what are your thoughts? If bad, can you explain because it has all the basic hallmarks that…Continue

Tags: Mantle

Is this Michael Jordan Autograph Legit?

Started this discussion. Last reply by AustinCollector Oct 10, 2024. 5 Replies

Alright thanks for all your help on the last one - two more signature to get your opinions on. Also have UD certifications (sent an email to UD) but would really appreciate your opinion on the…Continue

 

SeaEls's Page

Latest Activity

SeaEls posted a discussion

Pat Tillman - is it real?

I’m suspicious of basically everything despite having a PSA cert  (especially after Brett Lemieux) but this all seems to check out. It’s post 2009 PSA sticker and appears to be a basic cert from the database. The signature is a bit sloppy but the “photo of proof” wasn’t a from sanctioned signing event (I’m also skeptical of those). What are your thoughts?…See More
Sep 16
0 Comments
SeaEls replied to SeaEls's discussion Aaron Judge - Fanatics
"Good to know - thank you Terrier8HOF - really appreciate all of your input and taking the time to do this "
Jun 30, 2025
Eric Keith Longo replied to SeaEls's discussion Aaron Judge - Fanatics
"+2"
Jun 30, 2025
Scott Paul replied to SeaEls's discussion Aaron Judge - Fanatics
"+1"
Jun 30, 2025
Steve Cyrkin, Admin replied to SeaEls's discussion Aaron Judge - Fanatics
"I don't know Aaron Judge's autograph well. But Terrier8HOF is rarely wrong when he gives an authenticity opinion, and virtually never on baseball. If he says the Judge is not real you can take that to the bank."
Jun 30, 2025
SeaEls replied to SeaEls's discussion Aaron Judge - Fanatics
"Steve - Any thoughts on those lines on the Judge photo I posted? "
Jun 29, 2025
SeaEls replied to SeaEls's discussion Aaron Judge - Fanatics
"Seller is breakthebankautos  BUT I’m positive it was previously mistermancavellc which seller name is no longer “in business” but the link to break the bank has man cave framing as you can see…"
Jun 29, 2025
Steve Cyrkin, Admin replied to SeaEls's discussion Aaron Judge - Fanatics
"Is the…"
Jun 29, 2025
Eric Keith Longo replied to SeaEls's discussion Aaron Judge - Fanatics
"This is an earlier version of the sticker that is the shape of yours and the "F" is in a different location. From what was said here I'd avoid them at any rate. Here is the link to the Fanatics website with the different generations…"
Jun 29, 2025
SeaEls replied to SeaEls's discussion Aaron Judge - Fanatics
"Thanks Steve - I was hoping to get your input as well. Looks suspicious to me as well. Appreciate everyone responding!"
Jun 28, 2025
Steve Cyrkin, Admin replied to SeaEls's discussion Aaron Judge - Fanatics
"That does not look like a real sticker."
Jun 28, 2025
SeaEls replied to SeaEls's discussion Aaron Judge - Fanatics
"https://damilic.com/autopen-products/office-signature-machines it looks like nothing is safe anymore - I have a history with terrible customer service from Fanatics for anything that you yourself didn’t purchase directly from them in the…"
Jun 28, 2025
JK replied to SeaEls's discussion Aaron Judge - Fanatics
"That's very bad news about the new machines.  If you happen to have a link please post it.  Baseballs used to be safe. I would have said it doesn't look like an autopen but with that new machine who knows. I don't…"
Jun 28, 2025
SeaEls replied to SeaEls's discussion Aaron Judge - Fanatics
"why do you say that? I just found company that offers signature machines specifically advertised to sign sports equipment “baseballs, bats and mitts” - so it looks like it’s a thing.  Or do you mean that the signature…"
Jun 28, 2025
SeaEls replied to SeaEls's discussion Aaron Judge - Fanatics
"I agree with that as well"
Jun 28, 2025
JK replied to SeaEls's discussion Aaron Judge - Fanatics
"Its not an autopen on a baseball, that's for sure."
Jun 28, 2025

About Me

What kind of member are you? (Check as many as apply.)
Collector, Fan
What would you like to tell us about yourself, your collecting, or business.
Have a collection and have been selling some - interested in older historical sports items as well as some new items
What is your level of expertise?
Intermediate Collector
Why do you want to join Autograph Live?
Interested in learning, networking and getting authenticity opinions (and learning why they came to that option!)
Who can we thank for telling you about us?
Google
What are your areas of interest?
Sports, Modern Hollywood and Stage, Classic Hollywood and Stage
Why do you collect?
Sports autographs mainly baseball with some football and basketball
What is your favorite autograph in your collection?
Single Signed Connnie Mack, rookie Shohei or 1945 pirates ball with Honus Wagner
You can ask anyone living or dead for their autograph. Who would it be?
JFK
What is today's date?
September 29, 2024

Comment Wall

You need to be a member of Autograph Live to add comments!

Join Autograph Live

  • No comments yet!
 
 
 

Get Our Newsletter

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2026   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service