We're an eBay affiliate and may be compensated on purchases made through clicks. 

Not sure I’d be forking out any $’s for these autographs. IMO they lack the expected flow of a natural signature. Any other thoughts?

Views: 1846

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Wilson’s auctions, a small unknown auction house. I have a feeling people were calling this fake to discourage others. These are spot-on, proven by the fact that Tracks now has one.

No one here would call these fakes for any reason other than, from the photo provided, they simply didn't look right.

Opinions were then solicited and offered. There was nothing sinister about people commenting.

Your 'conspiracy' opinions are without merit and serve no purpose - other than exposing a lapse of judgement.

+1

+1 ??? Really, wow……

Still convinced these are “pattern forgeries” with the “forgerer sticking to a certain style”?

Nonsense. Its hard to admit that you think you know your stuff but actually dont - right? Hurt ego?

On the photo provided they looked right. Stop making nonsensical excuses. Just admit that you had no clue where you were talking about

No clue indeed, plus inventing stories why these would be fake. Unbelievable.

They didn’t look right?? Really. If you think these don’t look right then nothing will look right. They don’t come better than this. Near perfect, terrific genuine examples. I can’t see any valid argument above why these should be fakes, except they look the same. Well they SHOULD!

You’re correct I am exposing a lapse of judgement. Because no good arguments were given to call these fakes. And secondly because these are classic examples, which shouldn’t have been to hard to judge.

I don’t feel it’s right to give “opinions” without arguments. Statements like “When fans were lucky enough to meet any Beatle and get something signed...it was usually a napkin...maybe the back of a photo you had in your wallet or purse....etc. People didn't walk around with albums” are SPECULATION. The backstory made sense, the autographs look terrific so why make up a story about “napkins”?.

“From the photo provided, they simply didn't look right.”.
It seems you still have trouble admitting you had it completely wrong for four autographs that were an easy call. Sad…

no longer up on tracks website,  Maybe someone has purchased it already

Can that be determined?

Servi and Cornelis,

Treat other members with respect here. Don't be arrogant or demeaning. 

It appears that the same person is using the Servi and Cornelis member accounts. Is that right?

No, it’s not the same account. I only have one account here.

OK, I will not be arrogant anymore (the arrogance may not have been solely from my side though), but the confidence with which these were called fake, and the “arguments” that were given are not OK imo.
We all hate forgerers and we do everything we can to stop them, but it is quite something to putatively disadvantage an honest seller, while the autographs are perfectly fine and leave no doubts whatsoever.

RSS

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2024   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service