Sometimes I just get tired of seeing these all over eBay:

It's most frustrating when third-party authentication don't even put in the time to get it right. All I could find currently is one authenticated by PSA, but JSA have had their share too and the bottom one is from silentsaregolden on eBay. I've already messaged one of these sellers before and a couple others in the past.

Views: 1757

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

If PSA and JSA can't keep up with autopens and preprints of the world's biggest stars, it doesn't do a whole lot for their overall credibility.

I agree with you Richard.

Rubber stamp I presume.

All three above are exactly the same. You can see areas within the signature where the ink application is uneven and pooled... there are no flow lines. Definately rubber stamp.

i do notice on the last one, that there is a smear on the bottom part of the "K" in kirk... but that's not a signature smear.. that's a machine smear.

Correct… it’s most likely a skid mark from when the stamp was set down. It was probably set down at a slight angle and the lower left portion hit first and skidded a bit. That is why only a portion of the signature has the smear.

As it is with underwear, skid marks on a signature are bad. :-)

Mike, if they make a million mistakes, it should matter.  A lot!

Zipper is right that it's a stamp. I even own one. Douglas has been sending these out for years. I usually don't post this kind of stuff unless it's very easy to tell what I'm talking about (like when it's the same exact sig over and over again) because most people on this board have more experience in contemporary sports than things like this from vintage Hollywood actors. PSA and JSA can be pretty terrible with some of these old stars. Sometimes it feels like they don't even put in the requisite amount of time to actually look at an item and faithfully authenticate it.



  • Add Photos
  • View All


  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2023   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service