We're an eBay affiliate and may be compensated on purchases made through clicks. 

Is this Carrie Fisher alone okay or accurate or Authentic....?

Views: 575

Replies are closed for this discussion.

Replies to This Discussion

A beauty!  Thumbs up.

I have a couple of concerns about it, including the slant of the “F”.

I agree. It's very practiced and smooth, but atypical, as well as missing letters that Carrie usually doesn't skimp on. There's also several letters that are drawn with the wrong telemetry. I wouldn't touch this.

Well I had it certified and PSA said it was fine....

The point of hesitation there where the "F" originates might be enough to make me stay away.....but I'm betting this one has a good chance of getting the nod from any of the major authenticators.  If this is indeed a forgery, then there would be cause for collectors to doubt a lot of what may be in their SW collections.  It would certainly be a highly skilled attempt.

Highly skilled except for the dead stop and change of direction to correct the telemetry you noted in connecting the 'F'. But there are other tells here too, practiced and smooth (not drawn) as well as the connection flaw you mentioned. Where are the I and the e after Carr? I don't see it. Do you? The forger blew the end of the second r, what should have been the segue to the 'i' and rather smoothly ad-libbed, improvising the first and second name connection after the second 'r'. Now that is the reason why they lost their concentration for the 'F' connection! The 's' is also atypically shaped, the track not typical as well for her. And the last 'r' is not right.

general observations:

This forger is most definitely male, the pressure uniform and pen held more upright than at the angle that Carrie signs at. It's thick, plodding, and lacks the airy fluidity of Carrie's typically beautiful penmanship. It's practiced, it's done better than most, but still off the mark with lots of tells the major one being it's a man forging a woman's signature. Carrie's is always executed with what one might call a very "feminine" aspect to it. This is not.

48726a_lg.jpeg

Yep, agreed....it's the combo of the missing second "r" and the pause in the "f" that are indeed troubling.  It seems this was a decent attempt at the "ie" combo.  See the similarities to the one I posted, which I think is a good example to compare here.  But, yes I have never seen a real Carrie so rushed that it would not have included both "r" formations.  Otherwise, again, fairly well-done, and if a female forger ever gets in on the act we are really in trouble.  Fine work Woody2.

As I have said already, PSA DNA approved it with a letter and a sticker and that's all I need. I think you guys are slicing and dicing this a little too much. 

Thank you very much for your opinions. The first person is on the mark and agrees with PSA DNA. The only guy here.

KL

I don't collect this sig but the track change before the "F" and the odd "s" stood out to me as well. Perhaps others will have additional opinions. Please leave conversations that are still active open for additional comments.

But the first person changed their mind, no? Please leave active conversations open Kammie.

That is all you need to resell it. In most minds, PSA's certs go unquestioned, even if wrong, and in the case of this Fisher, IMO, and 100 cases here, some with before and after forged photos for irrefutable proof!

http://haulsofshame.com/blog/?p=26228 

Enjoy! You're welcome.

 

Thank you

RSS

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2024   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service