We are an eBay affiliate and may be compensated for clicks on links that result in purchases.
Had this one checked out by Roger Epperson who said it looks fine . Then it failed a Beckett quick opinion …I’ve previously had one failed by Beckett’s full inspection that Roger has guaranteed is genuine along with many other reliable people .
my question is has anyone else had bad experiences with Buckley and Beckett ?
Obviously I value Roger’s experience and opinion in music over there’s .
Tags:
Replies are closed for this discussion.
I don't know about the autograph itself but I have found that Beckett quick opinions are not worth a plug nickel. I've had positive quick opinions from them that failed when I submitted to them for a full authentication and failed quick opinions on signatures that have passed. I don't use them for quick opinions anymore.
+1
I have used Beckett quick opinion signature reviews several in the past. I'm in agreement with Joe W. above. On a couple of occasions I've simultaneously submitted an item to both them and PSA's version of quick opinion...and have had contradictory opinions given.
I personally now find it muddies the waters in attempting to access an item.
Was Roger's opinion a Quick Opinion as well or a full exam and cert? I see, a QO. I don't think anyone guarantees anything from a quick glance at a scan.
At least, with Roger, you know who is looking at your signature. With that said, if Roger's quick opinion is positive, send it in and get the paperwork.
I will be doing .
Twice they’ve let me down with Buckley’s .
I’ve used them for more common autographs but they really don’t help themselves denying anything they’re not 100000% sure On.
it’s exactly what was stated above , with Roger You know it’s him looking at it .
I've found Gary King to be very knowledgeable and helpful yoo .
Roger’s was just the quick opinion .
I value his opinion over theirs 100% as he has the actual knowledge and experience when it comes to Jeff and music related items. I have had a Buckley go in for full authentication and denied by Steve Grad but Roger looked at that and guaranteed me it was genuine !
I then made it my mission to get as many people to check it out as I could .
Jeff’s family members and friends have told me it’s without doubt authentic .
what I’m really trying to get at is how Beckett go about their quick opinions ?
If you were to ask me I would say they take one example and if it’s not an exact replica they deny it .
This post was never to doubt Roger more to find out people’s experience with Beckett .
safe to say I won’t be using again .
Roger has been my go to for a good few years and I’ve never been let down .
"...Roger looked at that and guaranteed me it was genuine !..."
From another QO?
"...
Jeff’s family members and friends have told me it’s without doubt authentic ..."
Not a good source.
Don't place so much value on Quick Opinions. For example, Quick Opinions and Pre-certs are not allowed to be used to assist a sale in the upcoming new Buy/Sell/Trade Forum - no matter who they come from.
I think I missed that as a condition in using the upcoming forum. I'm playing devil's advocate here: Why is that not allowed?
Some might make the point there is added credibility to a given piece if it has a positive quick opinion in addition to a seller and other members' opinions (as even more important as those are, of course).
It’s a service for a reason.
Ive generally only had positive interactions where Roger and Gary King are concerned …their knowledge is far superior than mine .
it’s the big corporations that don’t warrant it as it could be any Tom , Dick of Harry giving it one glance .
There is the very Recent All Things Must Pass thread. Pre-cert was incorrect.
Posted by CJCollector on November 11, 2024 at 6:03pm 0 Comments 1 Like
Posted by CJCollector on November 9, 2024 at 2:32pm 7 Comments 0 Likes
Posted by CJCollector on October 30, 2024 at 3:13pm 2 Comments 0 Likes
© 2024 Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin. Powered by
Badges | Report an Issue | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service