We are an eBay affiliate and may be compensated for clicks on links that result in purchases.

Feedback on the following autograph dealers, please

I am trying to get as much information so I can make a smart decision to buy!! Thanks, Jay

0 members like this

Comment by Rich on May 13, 2013 at 9:05am: I'd say Athlon looks pretty good, as I suspected. Prices don't seem too bad either.

Comment by Rich on May 13, 2013 at 9:22am: I'd stay away from Mainstream memorabilia. Their U2 items are terrible forgeries, there's a fake Harrison Ford for $75 and they have two dozen Daniel Radcliffe autographs available for about $35 - 75.

They've been discussed on the forum before:

http://live.autographmagazine.com/forum/topics/mainstream-memorabil...

Comment by Dale Stein on May 17, 2013 at 11:59am: Goldenstate is the only one I recognize and he is stellar, Grade A, and has been since I started collecting in the 90s. He is also on EBAY as "surfinsafari505" One of the finest, I just can't say enough good things .

Comment by James Collins on December 18, 2014 at 9:49am: Everyone should be careful from every company. Autographwarehouse has never failed JSA or PSA authentication on an item, thats a fact. We carry very few items that we dont see signed in person and those items are from private signings, signing inventory from larger well known companies or from a few long term collectors we grew up chasing autographs with in NYC. I appreciate the customers comments and business above, but 95% of the items the customer has purchased from us have not had JSA or PSA etc but just our AW Authentication numbered hologram and certification. So the be careful comment is confusing in that sense as we are one of the reputable companies. Again we have never sold an item that failed JSA or PSA and we never will. You can call our company and try and sell us anything, we dont buy anything from the general public, nobody walks in sells us anything, we carry what we know. So many people in this industry make so much more money by buying things from anybody. We spend so much money paying athletes to sign balls, pucks and most of all CARDS from signings its beyond imagination. Autographwarehouse takes authentication very seriously. A company is only as good as its reputation. Again Autographwarehouse AW Authentic has never failed JSA or PSA and we NEVER will. Jim Autographwarehouse

Comment by James Collins on December 18, 2014 at 3:31pm: Yes everyone should do research, it is sad the stuff people purchase on ebay etc, that I have seen given as gifts or purchased by people and then they show me. Sorry I had to respond in a certain way to this 2 year old post as google has recently, well goggled, this page and located it high with our name associated, and I needed to add a response that can be seen when that page is goggled by other people. We appreciate your business. Thanks Jim

Comment by VolFins on December 18, 2014 at 3:43pm: No worries Jim and I completely understand. I deleted my comments so that any future searches won't be misconstrued as negativity with you guys. I look forward to doing business with you again in the future.