I do not like this at all. I won't have time over the weekend but I think more of us should utilize editing software in this way and compare as many examples as we can. I can start again next week.
What's strange is, I went to a PSA event yesterday in schererville Indiana and they had a deal that felt too good to be true. Anything under $49 regular pricing was $15. I had 37 items authenticated just for the hell of it when all I wanted was to add Jane Curtin to my now complete original SNL cast vinyl previous authentication sticker and request a new LOA.. it felt like a money grab and I'm curious if they also know something.. trying to get as much money as they can now before things blow up?... Or are these deals a normal occurrence? I rarely bother with authentication service and have no clue but I felt like something was up with that too.. like why were they so cheap? Hopefully this is normal and I'm just overthinking but I drove over 500 miles yesterday to attend that event instead of going to a major convention waiting in line all day. I was actually going to make a post about it but was totally distracted today.
This definitely seems to be fishy.. soon, everything may require a witness sticker, photo, video, and a piece of hair for some DNA attached to every autograph..
Yeah, you can overlay two photos from your library using the Shortcuts app on iPhone. The steps are a little tedious but once you get the photos in there, it’s pretty easy to use. I encourage everyone to try it and start with the two from Tobysautographs.
I honestly don’t know what to make of it. Something just feels off when looking at them, and taking into account the number signed, age/health, etc. Then looking at those two I reposted from tobysautographs, along with the overlays. It’s not exact, and I’m not saying we can gain anything from isolating parts of a letter that may look similar across different signatures. But multiple points seem to be lining up in a way that they shouldn’t, suggesting mechanical involvement? Or maybe like you said, she signed so many that there are just going to be similarities. I don’t know. I pulled two other random examples and did not get much to line up like in the ones I posted.
Congrats btw on getting your SNL completed, that’s awesome.
This is an older one from a European auction where the picture is available but attached to an auction long closed and deleted so no info.. it has a small tail on the z, and the a is a known style as well. This matches up with the style in her book. I am a bit exhausted and need a break so you guys be the judge...
I'm getting more confident that these books are in her hand but it's still not conclusive. But more research needed for Matt M.'s amazing catch at a possible advanced autopen machine being used. Or is it possible she signed so much that some aspects are exact from each other.. almost impossible in this way no?
Anyways, here is the older signature from the euro auction (not confirmed authentic but matches others in ways) compared to her book. The L's the angles, the placement.. I say her hand but we might have bigger problems now.
Thank you for your great detective work on this Matt M..
Now you've got me leaning towards the opinion that these are going
to turn out to be bad.
Your theory of autopen with hybrid templates may be spot on.
Why can't these artists just legitimately sign, and stop being so lazy and sneaky?
I guess we'll see with Liza as more exemplars emerge.
JJ
Glad to help…I still don’t know what to make of these either. I agree that the varying pressure, lack of dots, and lack of exact matches would all support them being by hand. If they are secretarial, they are pretty good compared to her known examples…and consistent, considering that the signer would have had to replicate her signature thousands of times. I still feel like there is possibly mechanical involvement but would need to compare more examples.
Yes, I think more exemplars are in order. I will post mine when I get around to picking it up. JJ
I've read a bunch of pages of debate here. I'm in London where a number of stores had signed copies. I picked one up from a small independent in a seaside town. How is that possible? To satisfy UK and US market she'd have to sign thousands. And yes, they all looked the same. I've formally asked the UK publisher to confirm. But I'm just reading wish fulfillment here. We must, surely, accept that we've been done wrong by the publishers. Cheated and been misled. What we're seeing is just not possible. Where do we go from here?
That’s a good question Gareth, one I’ve actually been thinking about today.
As for this specific Liza mess, I’ve been so busy that I haven’t even started the return on my own Liza book yet. My understanding is that we have 30 days with Barnes & Noble, and I think other retailers have similar policies. But I’m curious if anyone has run into any roadblocks with returns.
I also don’t expect the publisher or Liza’s team to be in any hurry to acknowledge anything, so a refund may be about as resolved as it’s going to get. I do hope that the point has been made….we are aware of how far they went with this one, and maybe that gives them pause next time. I think we need media attention to drive that point home.
I have shelves full of these signed books, and I don’t doubt that the vast majority are genuine. I’m trying not to toss out the good with the bad so to speak.
That said, I picked up the Michael Douglas book the other day before thinking better of it, but passed on the Christopher Lloyd book (which normally I would have bought).
I think the dust needs to settle a bit before I feel comfortable moving forward with collecting these again, especially when we’re talking about people of advanced age who are supposedly mass-signing thousands of copies. It does make me wonder whether some books we already own might have involved this kind of technology or better, and got by us.
Also Gareth and anyone else landing on this thread- I just want to make sure you know about the specific Autopen thread created for the Liza books:
You’re welcome to post in either, but you might be interested in this if you haven’t read through it:
https://live.autographmagazine.com/forum/topics/liza-minnelli-kids-...
© 2026 Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.
Powered by
Badges | Report an Issue | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service