Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Carl Ryan on December 23, 2012 at 11:41pm

I definetly am not being a cynic, but who would take a genuine hat and make a fake sig on it? Michael Bush. He just finished doing that with hundreds of items in the Julian auction. If a forger thought he could get more money out of an item if signed, then you better believe they will slap a sign on it. Ive seen many important valuable pieces of memorabilia ruined by fake signatures. It just has to do with how much they can get out of it. I cant comment on the MJ signature. Roger will definetly be the guy who can tell you though. If he says good, then you can pretty much take it to the bank.

But a hat or other such item where a shaky or unusual signature can be explained b/c of the item itself, is a perfect target for forgers. So its really hard to tell sometimes. I read the sellers story and its no different from the countless other forgers out their. But that certainly is not saying that its fake, just that i wouldnt put two cents worth into the story. And a forger would try many times before putting it on the hat, if he was experienced at all. Not only that, but when looking at the hat, the signature would actually be quite easy to fake. These are just a few things to consider. But the hat may be a great authentic piece, you just never know. Forgers are clever.

I hope it turns out good for you, but please dont think someone wont screw up an important item with a fake signature. Another great example is the Thriller Jacket sold for 1.8 million i think. From what ive heard, its likely that was a Michael Bush as well. But we all know by now that Bush scribbled Michaels name on tons of amazing historic pieces. And you have to ask yourself, why would he do it? Its not like it really should affect bidding that much. If they are real the real pieces then they should go for near just as much as an autographed piece. If someone is going to spend 1 million dollars on a jacket, i sincerely doubt that the autograph plays much part at all in the deal. So you just cant tell with the crooks out their, they will do anything. 

Let us know what Roger says. I hope its good.

Carl

Permalink Reply by Agustin Cela Blazquez on December 23, 2012 at 11:50pm

Hi Carl,
I didnt knew the Julian Auction Story. Wow, thats unbelievable.
Yes, im with you, i would tell the same story about the hat, you only need to know a bit about where Michael was in what year.
I wrote to Roger yesterday, maybe i should make the 15,00 payment?

Permalink Reply by Carl Ryan on December 23, 2012 at 11:55pm

Agustin,

Yeah the Julians auction story is nuts. Their is a huge thread on it on this site. If you do a forum search youll find it. Just type in Julians and forgery and you will see. The thread presents undeniable evidence the items sold that were autographed, were pretty much all signed by Michael Bush, their desiger. The handwriting is blatantly obviously the same as Bush's. 

Both Julians and Bush are now up sh#ts creek now b/c of this. Because of this website getting the word out their, it even made the news, and buyers were urged to get their items checked out. Julians said they would honor returns if anyone wanted them, but they are lying. They arent responding to anyone wanting to return their items. It really is shocking. It certainly is worth the read.

You may want to make the payment as Roger gives free opinions here but its more of an every now and then thing i think. If your really interested, id pay the fee. If he says good, then your in good shape. I wish you the best

carl

Permalink Reply by Agustin Cela Blazquez on December 24, 2012 at 12:00am

I also made a opinion order at http://www.didtheysignit.com/experts.htm

They are the same as www.autographsale.net

Some opinion about them?

Permalink Reply by A.B. on December 24, 2012 at 2:18am

I´m not an expert, but I don´t think this is genuine.

Permalink Reply by Prashant Kaushik on December 24, 2012 at 7:12am

I am confident the signature is fake. You can't even compare with the other signed fedora which is 10000% genuine. It was signed to dieter weisner, a good friend of his from Germany. Just compare the pen pressure in both signatures. It almost looks as though the forger was trying to make a very poor attempt in duplicating the signature from the real signed fedora. I am sure roger will say it is not even close to being genuine.

Permalink Reply by Agustin Cela Blazquez on December 24, 2012 at 7:26am

For me all are different, the one on http://signedsealeddel.com/search.php

are different than the one on http://www.thesignaturelibrary.com/products-details.php?&cat_id...

and the one on http://autographsale.net/music/michael-jackson/michael-jackson-auto...

The last is also very similar for me.

and on this one http://autographsale.net/music/michael-jackson/michael-jackson-auto... the M is also broken

Permalink Reply by roger epperson on December 24, 2012 at 7:33am

Hello

I don't believe the signature on the hat is authentic.  It is much harder making a opinion call on something like a hat as it is not s stable surfaice to sign on; however there too many things wrong with this.  Look at the the way he spelled Michael> it appears to be signed "Miich" it is also signed much too slow.

Permalink Reply by Agustin Cela Blazquez on December 24, 2012 at 7:50am

Hello Roger,

did you compare it to the other dedicated hat? and to the autographsale.net?

He signed it at home with time and the autograph is very big, don´t know if its easy to sign quick.

For me it is no problem, i can send it back, it was bought at ebay and paid with paypal.

But it seemed to me genuine.

Are you sure?

Many thanks

Permalink Reply by Agustin Cela Blazquez on December 24, 2012 at 9:09am

Roger,

if so, can you please send me an email with your opinion so i can send it to the seller too.

thx

Permalink Reply by Agustin Cela Blazquez on December 24, 2012 at 9:15am

on this one and most autographs on thesignature library the i seems to be more than once, on most there is no h defined but on this i mean to see two i and the h too

http://www.thesignaturelibrary.com/products-details.php?&cat_id...

Permalink Reply by Agustin Cela Blazquez on December 24, 2012 at 9:29am

I will not compare anymore autographs, i have 3 opinion with "not genuine" and waiting for another opinion. I will send it back and forget it. Many thanks to all. Roger, when you can, please send me the mail. I think you´re right, the double ii does not look good.

• ‹ Previous
• 1
• 2
• 3
• 4
• 5
• 6
• Next ›
• Page