Hello all!

I received this autographed photo as a gift. If you look up Sabrina Carpenter’s signature it doesn’t look close. The seller is trying to gaslight us by saying that he purchased it from a reputable dealer. If you have a moment to please take a look and give your opinions for our peace of mind to continue pursuing a return. 

Tags: Carpenter, Sabrina

Views: 233

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Additionally, the certificate of authenticity comes from 5 stars autographs. 

Link?

https://www.etsy.com/listing/1829235608/sabrina-carpenter-autograph...

here was the post it’s from Etsy. Below is a link to the shop where the seller sells other autographs 

https://www.etsy.com/shop/LifeStylesMarketing

 

This is a forgery seller. Madonna for $45. Fast & Furious cast photos with Walker for $50-60. Case closed there. All premium items from top stars at rock bottom prices. This guy also isn't nearly as good a forger as he thinks.

That's also not really how Carpenter signs.

Paul Walker for $50-$60? Yeah right🤣

eBay or? Item #?

Bob Dylan signed photo for $45 BUY IT NOW & FREE SHIPPING? RUN! I would obviously return this and buy a certified example that meets with approval here. The signature is very minimal and perhaps easy to forge. You can get her slabbed for about $90+ - double but peace of mind as long as it checks out.

Thank you for your response. The seller is being extremely rude and defensive about our return, so I just wanted to get other opinions on the matter. 

Yeah that's a red flag in my opinion I'd send it back, if they are getting upset and rude about it.

Do they not have a 30 day return policy? Link them to this discussion. You can not buy Bob Dylan for $45.  Why would someone offer something that would be worth a tremendous amount more for $54 Buy It Now with Free Shipping? Let's look at the Dylan:

Photographs are not loading. I am sorry. 

He claims that he does have a 30 day return policy but he dragged his feet about sending a return address and has also reiterated multiple times to send the item back in original condition. We plan to send the item carefully wrapped and ship with photo and video evidence. He also claims that we are the first out of 500 purchases that has questioned the authenticity. 

I think to see the pictures you have to click on them individually to see the full image.

Guy is an absolute fraudster. The items are fake. He's either lying about his track record or has gotten lucky on the basis of the purchasers having no clue that what they bought was fake.

"Original condition" is laughable. It's worthless trash.

RSS

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2025   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service