I tried calling the number on his website but got an answering machine with a woman saying she can’t come to the phone right now. No mention of a business. I want to get a quick opinion from him regarding an Ebay auction. Anyone speak to him lately?

Views: 1705

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I've always used his email contact.

Is he legit? There’s lots of articles about him floating around. Lots of negative stuff. I’m new to the autograph world and so far I haven’t bought anything because I don’t feel confident about it. Who do I trust?
If you search you will find negative feedback about every authenticator out there. (PSA, JSA, Beckett, etc...)

As with all of them they have made mistakes, but I have seen Roger own up to his if he does...Which is more then other authenticators do.

He is very knowledgeable and I have used his quick opinion service and also have purchased direct. Never tried the phone number, I have only emailed him.

What is nice that he is an individual and not a corporation like the rest, so you know he is the one doing the authenticating and not some faceless individual at one of the other places...But he is only human and while an expert in music authentication, it is always smart to get multiple opinions and do your own research too.

Hope that helps.
I agree with Adam completely. Roger is an expert and trustworthy. Human beings can make mistakes in such a subjective field, but I’d much rather work with Roger than the alternatives.
Thanks for the replies. Being new to this I’m finding the business very strange. Unless you see it being signed in front of you how do you really know it’s real? Even experts make mistakes right? You could go your whole life believing you have an authentic autograph and then one day somebody shoots it down. Who do you believe then? I’m not a collector and am only looking for one item specifically but am finding it hard trusting the industry. It seems with so many fraudulent items out there odds are you’ll get a fake before ever getting a real one. Please someone reassure me.

No one can completely "reassure you" as there is risk involved with every business -- especially the autograph one. I'd advise posting the one you concerned about on this site as you will get some good opinions. Then it is up to you to decide. 

So you are doing the best thing, asking questions first before buying a major purchase that could likely be fake. That is the first step.

What is nice about a place like Autograph Magazine Live is, it is full of like minded collectors that can give great advice and likely have studied the individual you are looking to purchase.

It is very smart to gain opinions, look at other examples of autographs from the same time frame, look at these points of reference.

If you are purchasing from someone on ebay (for example) look to see what else they sell. Are there red flags? 100% feedback alone doesn't mean they are trustworthy by itself.

There are many cautionary tales before buying anything without being educated. Be educated first before buying...That is my best advice.

If you post examples here you are likely to get good opinions. Good luck and welcome to AML, you are on the right track!
Thanks, that’s a good idea. I’ll post some pics in the other forum. It’s true what you said. Educating yourself before getting involved in anything could save you some grief down the road.

I've had a very negative experience with him. He is not a good authenticator. And terrible businessman. Avoid.

Ger Ryan,

Please know that Roger has been involved in the collecting, selling and more importantly the study of R&R Signatures as far back (as I can testify) to the mid 1980's, when I first met him at The NAMM shows (obtaining Don Felder's signature). He has been at this for probably what amounts to half his life. I have seen him at countless trade and convention shows and always buried up to his elbows in autographed memorabilia. He was at this long before Ebay and the internet, and he was dang near an expert even back then. He's two things in my book: Extremely experienced and also human. It will be tough to find anyone better.

My three cents.

I agree. He’s helped me A LOT and saved me from buying fakes several times.

Does he make mistakes? I’m sure he does. But to me, he’s still the best in the business by a wide margin.

Thanks Stephen, I appreciate your input. As I've shown here I'm a bit of an expert on U2, I've got them so many times in person, and I'm asked often for my opinion. I know when it's a yes, and I know when it's a nooooo.
But frankly, when I don't know I say I don't know. 
Roger may be the best at what he does, I'll give you that. 
But he should have the respect to answer someone's emails when that person knows to a certainty that Roger called it wrong.
My two cents, respectfully. Cheers



  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2020   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service