Mantle, Williams and DiMaggio: Authenticating Baseball Forger Favorites

It is unquestionable that Mickey Mantle, Ted Williams, and Joe DiMaggio have been American sports icons since the mid-20th century. It comes as no surprise that these three have been favorites of autograph collectors since the advent of autograph and card shows in the 1980’s. Unfortunately it is equally unsurprising, as attested to in the FBI’s famous 1990s Operation Bullpen, that they are also the three most forged sports autographs. Although most experts believe the forgery problem in sports memorabilia has lessoned tremendously since Operation Bullpen (estimated at that time to be “between $500,000,000 and $900,000,000” by the FBI), sadly large numbers of forged material still exist.

While it would require far more than a single article to educate the autograph collector to detect Mantle, Williams and DiMaggio forgeries, there are some general as well as specific warning keys to these three autographs that may aid in detecting possible forgeries.

Genuine Mantle, Williams & DiMaggio signed photo provided by EAC Gallery.
Click to enlarge:

As a general rule, one of the first things I examine in an autograph is its feel – how it was written. When an individual signs his name there should be an easy, smooth flow to the signature. We’ve all signed our names countless times, and we don’t need to think about it. An item we offered in one of our past auctions was a sheet of paper signed several times by Joe Jackson. Jackson, who was almost completely illiterate, actually had to practice, in essence work at, writing his name prior to signing documents. Likewise, when a forger writes a signature, he or she is working at it and therefore upon close examination it’s often possible to detect such warning keys as a slowness of motion, stops and starts at inappropriate spots, and possibly even a shakiness in the writing. An invaluable aid to help detect these keys, taught to me by John Reznikoff of University Archives many years ago, is to turn the autograph upside down. When you view an autograph in an unnatural position these warning keys are often easier to detect.

In addition to such general warning keys there are specific warning keys, unique to an individual’s autograph, to keep an eye out for.

In the 1980’s and 1990’s Mickey Mantle stated on numerous occasions that he was blessed to be able to earn more money signing his name at one single weekend show than his father had earned in an entire year working as a coal miner. Because of this Mantle always felt his fans were deserving of a clear, elegant signature. In authentic Mickey Mantle autographs Mickey would always end the “y” in “Mickey” on an upswing, and because he would be quickly flowing through his signature, he therefore started the “M” in “Mantle” on a higher level or plane than he had started the “M” in “Mickey”. Most forgers, because they were “working” on writing Mantle’s signature, would pause after completing “Mickey” and begin anew in writing “Mantle”, therefore placing “Mantle” on more of a straight line with “Mickey”. If one places a ruler or sheet of paper straight across the item Mantle signed (not straight across the signature) all that appears below the ruler or paper of an authentic Mantle is the bottom portion of the “M” in “Mickey”. In the case of most forgeries the ruler or paper completely covers the entire signature. Another difficulty forgers have with Mantle’s signature was his unique way of looping the bottom portion of his “M”. Such curved lines were executed in one easy movement by Mantle, but are most often elongated by forgers who again are “working” the signature. Such slow, elongated forgeries are especially easy to recognize on baseballs as their curved surfaces only add to the forger’s difficulty.

In the case of Ted Williams autographs, with the exception of the capital “W” in Williams, Ted would consistently make the size of all the letters in his last time nearly the same exact size. Most telling is the “illia”, with the “l”s just ever so slightly taller than the “i”s, and the “a” as tall as the “l”s. Try as they may, most forgers simply can’t undo years of training and habit causing their “l”s to be significantly taller than their “i”s, and their “a” significantly shorter than their “l”s. Williams also connected the “W” in “Williams” to the “ed” in “Ted” with a swirl that gave forgers difficulty in replicating in the same, easy, flowing movement as appears in authentic examples. Also of interest, in addition to the many Williams intentional forgeries in existence, Williams revealed late in his life that during his playing days his signature on team signed balls was often a “clubhouse” example, not penned by him.

Regarding Joe DiMaggio’s autograph, problems for forgers begin with the first letter in Joe. Like the “M”s in Mantle’s autograph, the “J” in “Joe”, which appears as two loops, a larger loop on top and a smaller one below, were created by curved lines which are the hardest to duplicate without leaving telltale signs of slowness or inappropriate stops and starts. In addition, DiMaggio would pen his “J”s so that the lower loop would be written on top of (literally written over) the upper loop in two places. For some inexplicable reason, a significant percentage of DiMaggio forgeries flow in the opposite direction, with the upper loop covering the lower one. An inexpensive magnifier or jeweler’s loop will aid in viewing this detail. Finally, the general feel of an authentic DiMaggio autograph is often somewhat sloppy, in the sense that the spacing between letters is uneven, obviously much more so in his second name. Again due to the fact that forgers are working rather than simply signing, the spacing they place between each letter is far more uniform.

Finally, the age-old adage “experience is the best teacher” is indeed appropriate here. The building of as extensive a library of exemplars as possible, of both authentic and fake examples, would be of help to visualize these and additional warning keys, and tremendously assist in the detection of forgeries.

Tags: authenticate, baseball, dimaggio, fame, forgeries, forgers, genuine, hall, hof, joe, More…mantle, mickey, of, ted, williams

9 members like this

▶ Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Null on February 17, 2013 at 6:44pm

Operation Bullpen forgery listed by eBay seller swainer23

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Mickey-Mantle-Autographed-Auto-New-York-Yan...

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by CJCollector on February 17, 2013 at 6:55pm

Yep, the seller (Ebay seller swainer23) with the small images. That's an ugly forgery (like most are).

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Null on February 18, 2013 at 8:41am

Operation Bullpen Forgery on a 16x20 listed by eBay seller masterblasterr BIN for ONLY $1,300

http://www.ebay.com/itm/MICKEY-MANTLE-AUTOGRAPHED-NEW-YORK-YANKEES-...

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Null on February 18, 2013 at 8:43am

Same seller masterblasterr has another 16x20 piece of crap for ONLY $1,300 BIN.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/MICKEY-MANTLE-SIGNED-AUTOGRAPHED-NEW-YORK-Y...

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by CJCollector on February 18, 2013 at 6:57pm

At the prices EBay seller masterblasterr wants for his Mickey Mantle forgeries, they are guaranteed not to sell.

Even the wannabe autograph collectors who usually buy that crap, aren't going to pay that kind of mind for those Mickey Mantle forgeries listed by EBay seller masterblasterr.

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Null on February 18, 2013 at 8:50am

A couple turds over on ubid.com with COA's from GFA. Both come in intricate frames/matting to disguise the horrific forgery.

http://www.ubid.com/Mickey_Mantle_-_Lt._Ed._Autographed_Centerpiece...

http://www.ubid.com/%22Center_of_New_York%22_Mickey_Mantle_-_Lt._Ed...

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Steve Zarelli on February 18, 2013 at 10:20am

I wonder what Heritage Auction would think of this auction text:

Heritage Memorabilia brings you the most elite selection of custom designs to deliver limited edition generational heirlooms. Our expert attention to detail shows you the extraordinary amount of pride Heritage takes in producing these historically significant creations.

These completely custom, high quality pieces are held to the highest standards on the marketplace. In a retail store, a single dimensional mat starts at $100 while elaborate multi-dimensional matting can cost in excess of $500. Heritage strives to deliver remarkable value while giving each customer a championship moment.

These limited productions unite the historical greatness of image and time to create must-have centerpieces for every distinguished collection.

Each autograph goes through GFA's industry leading forensic authentication process to ensure that every piece comes with a certified genuine signature. Our exquisite multi-layer matting with innovative multidimensional cut treatments give captivating new looks into iconic logos, legendary retired numbers, immortalizing engraved plaques, and much more!

Heritage Memorabilia: Enshrine Your Memories

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Steve Zarelli on February 18, 2013 at 10:21am

I've been half-tempted to get one of these on the cheap just for the matting. Remove the junky fake and insert a real deal from my collection But then, I can't bring myself to support these scammers with 1 cent of my money.

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Null on February 18, 2013 at 9:14am

Holy crap I did some Craiglist investigating and it is INSANE how many forgeries are on there. Out of the 50 or so I saw, 2-3 were authentic. NOTE TO THE UNWISE/AMATEUR COLLECTOR: DO NOT BUY FROM CRAIGSLIST. Here are some dog crap examples I just came across, I couldn't begin to save all of the images:

▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Null on February 18, 2013 at 11:57am

Monkey Mantle listed by eBay seller amc2344 , in fact I want to thank this auction because it just reminded me I have a banana in my drawer to eat. =)

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Mickey-Mantle-Signed-Baseball-No-reserve-/1...