PLEASE ASK QUESTIONS IN THE DISCUSSION FORUMS, NOT BLOGS.
READ THIS BEFORE YOU POST, THANKS.

Robert Tomaka
  • Lake Forest, CA
  • United States
Share on Facebook
Share

Robert Tomaka's Friends

  • Steve

Robert Tomaka's Groups

Robert Tomaka's Discussions

500 HR Club Signed Baseball

Started this discussion. Last reply by Steve May 21. 2 Replies

Hello All! Im looking at this auction online that is for a 500 homerun club signed baseball with a COA that the seller mentions but does not mention again in the listing. Might be an oversight by the…Continue

Could this Alleged Mickey Mantle Auto Be the Deal of the Year? Opinions Please !

Started this discussion. Last reply by Steve May 9. 3 Replies

aI couldn’t pass up an opportunity to potentially grab a Mantle auto for…Continue

Tags: HOF, Yankees, Mantle

Need Some Opinions on this Joltin Joe

Started this discussion. Last reply by Fuddjcal May 9. 8 Replies

Hey All!I am back again looking for some opinions on this Joe DiMaggio auto being sold locally on the app OfferUp. Says it comes with some no name COA, and probably would have caused less suspicion…Continue

Tags: Yankees, DiMaggio, Joe

Opinions on this Mike Trout Inscribed and Signed Helmet?

Started this discussion. Last reply by Rick Meyer May 5. 10 Replies

Hi Everyone,I appreciate how prompt you all have been in getting back to me regarding my authentication questions. I've asked previously about Trout autographs, and am often 50/50 in terms of my own…Continue

Gifts Received

Gift

Robert Tomaka has not received any gifts yet

Give a Gift

 

Robert Tomaka's Page

Latest Activity

Steve replied to Robert Tomaka's discussion 500 HR Club Signed Baseball
"Very fake."
May 21
terrier8HOF replied to Robert Tomaka's discussion 500 HR Club Signed Baseball
"not your typical 500 club forgery, but still a forgery.  The Mantle is obvious."
May 21
Robert Tomaka posted a discussion

500 HR Club Signed Baseball

Hello All! Im looking at this auction online that is for a 500 homerun club signed baseball with a COA that the seller mentions but does not mention again in the listing. Might be an oversight by the seller, but to not include which company the authentication comes from or anything else about authenticity, seems a little fishy but the signatures look decent in my opinion. Would love to hear from you all on this one. Thanks in advance !Rob…See More
May 21
Steve replied to Robert Tomaka's discussion Could this Alleged Mickey Mantle Auto Be the Deal of the Year? Opinions Please !
"This is clearly a fake and once again comes complete with a BS story from a seller who knows it is fake."
May 9
Fuddjcal replied to Robert Tomaka's discussion Need Some Opinions on this Joltin Joe
"They OFFER UP FORGERIES is what they do. LOL. Nothing but fakes there PERIOD. Please stop it."
May 9
Fuddjcal replied to Robert Tomaka's discussion Could this Alleged Mickey Mantle Auto Be the Deal of the Year? Opinions Please !
" It's a fake forgery because it is. An E4G (erratic 4th grader) could tell it's a fake the second they lay eyes on it, IMHO. "
May 9
D R replied to Robert Tomaka's discussion Could this Alleged Mickey Mantle Auto Be the Deal of the Year? Opinions Please !
"It looks slowly drawn, not signed.  I’m no expert so see what others say.  But if a non-expert would avoid it..."
May 9
Robert Tomaka posted a discussion

Could this Alleged Mickey Mantle Auto Be the Deal of the Year? Opinions Please !

aI couldn’t pass up an opportunity to potentially grab a Mantle auto for $25 so again, i went fishing on my local OfferUp App and found this alleged Mickey Mantle autograph, which was signed on what appeared to be a page from a baseball program from the 1960’s. No paperwork, provenance, or COA to be found, but the seller stated his dad had picked it up at a card show in…See More
May 9
Robert Tomaka replied to Robert Tomaka's discussion Need Some Opinions on this Joltin Joe
"Thank you for checking this one out. It’s always comforting  to hear a unanimous opinion "
May 9
Robert Tomaka replied to Robert Tomaka's discussion Need Some Opinions on this Joltin Joe
"Thanks for taking the time to let me know. Very appreciated!"
May 9
Rick Meyer replied to Robert Tomaka's discussion Opinions on this Mike Trout Inscribed and Signed Helmet?
"Here are two examples of in person rushed signatures. I would normally say no to them if shown these. I saw them signed but when they look like this I’d rather error one the side of caution. Plus who would want a Trout that looks like this?"
May 5
Rick Meyer replied to Robert Tomaka's discussion Opinions on this Mike Trout Inscribed and Signed Helmet?
"Here are a couple more showing another version of his signature. The magazine I got signed and the license plate my brother did and I saw video of it being signed. These are authentic."
May 5
Rick Meyer replied to Robert Tomaka's discussion Opinions on this Mike Trout Inscribed and Signed Helmet?
"These are the ones I previously posted. Redoing them so they show in the thread. These are 100% authentic."
May 5
Rick Meyer replied to Robert Tomaka's discussion Opinions on this Mike Trout Inscribed and Signed Helmet?
"These were authenticated by one of the Authenticators you mention. What do you think of them? "
May 5
Rick Meyer replied to Robert Tomaka's discussion Opinions on this Mike Trout Inscribed and Signed Helmet?
"This one looks good. Trout signature has changed a bit. The PSA one above I still wouldn’t buy. Don’t think it’s good. The grade just has to do with the ink placement and such. Bad signatures they authenticate get graded too."
May 5
BlueBlood replied to Robert Tomaka's discussion Opinions on this Mike Trout Inscribed and Signed Helmet?
"This ball is similar to the PSA authenticated ball but was authenticated by both JSA and BAS.  Agree that neither looks similar to the signed ball you posted.  Has his signature changed much over the years?"
May 5

About Me

What kind of member are you? Industry professionals must use their real names and identify themselves as such. (Check as many as apply.)
Collector, Fan
Who can we thank for telling you about Autograph Live?
google
What do you collect, or want to collect?
Sports
Tell us more about your collection, specific areas of interest, etc.:
Vintage hall of fame 1900s memorabilia
What is your level of expertise?
Intermediate Collector, Advanced Collector

Robert Tomaka's Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

Comment Wall

You need to be a member of Autograph Live to add comments!

Join Autograph Live

  • No comments yet!
 
 
 

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2020   Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service