Authentication and Forgery Alert


Authentication and Forgery Alert

Discuss authentication issues within the industry, including but not limited to 3rd party authentication. It's also a "clearing house" for suspected forgeries.

Members: 377
Latest Activity: Aug 21

Discussion Forums

What Do You Think About The Autographs Sold By This Seller?

Started by Daniel Alayof. Last reply by Chad B Aug 21. 1 Reply

Hi. I would appreciate your opinion about this seller and the autographs that he recently sold. Please click on the link to see his sold autographs. What do you think?…Continue

Anatomy of a forger?

Started by JJ. Last reply by sling Jan 4. 1 Reply

You may have noticed that the book "A Wrinkle in Time" by Madeleine L'Engle will soon be a blockbuster movie from Disney. I loved that book when I was in elementary school, and I remember the author…Continue Forgeries!

Started by Sandie Strickland. Last reply by Christopher Williams Oct 24, 2017. 44 Replies

I purchased 2 items from one being a signed poster of Rebel without a Cause by James Dean claiming to be an original 1950's German poster when it arrived it was nothing like the one…Continue

Peyton Manning Jersey

Started by Lisa. Last reply by Steve Cyrkin Community Mgr. Jul 9, 2017. 1 Reply

Sent the attached Peyton Manning jersey to JSA and it came back with a COA. However, I seen one of your threads that now has me concerned. Help please!

Comment Wall


You need to be a member of Authentication and Forgery Alert to add comments!

Comment by Rick Badwey on September 29, 2010 at 7:17am
People who say disparaging things about John Reznikoff do NOT really know him. I have known John for over 20 years and have never seen him represent something other than what it is. And, out of the many things I have framed for John and his clients, I have never observed any misrepresented items. For John to have to resign form PADA amazes me. If he were that bad, he would have been tossed out of ABAA. The guy has been part of the reason for the success of the industry. He knows his stuff, and he is a great marketer. He handles great material (except Obama's car) He is very successful and I see the people who attack him are just simply jealous. And allegations of him being pompous are false. The guy is is very busy balancing a life of a business and family. There are times I call him and he is busy shuffling kids to Basketball or other scholastic events. It says a lot about someone and his character who puts his family first.
Comment by john reznikoff on September 29, 2010 at 6:39am
I knew he pulled the same kind of stunt on you with some phonied up albums. I never paid any heed to it nor did anyone I know. After about 1 paragraph it just seemed like some rambling illiterate mess. I dont think the drible on his site is good enough to qualify as Sunday Funnies in a newspaper. Maybe a tongue and cheek farce in some student run junior high school paper
Comment by Rob James on April 25, 2010 at 5:02am
And yet another fully signed INXS guitar from the same business Backstage Autographs (owner C Lancaster a UACC member apparently) bought from a collection in the, how lucky, 2 in 2 weeks. Can't wait for next week........
Comment by Rob James on April 22, 2010 at 5:54am
Thanks Roger, I would have passed this by you though I had limited time at the time.
Comment by roger epperson on April 22, 2010 at 5:36am
You are correct, that is an awful forgery.
Comment by Rob James on April 21, 2010 at 7:07pm
This item was recently listed (and sold) in Australia by a business called Backstage Autographs of whom any information cannot be found. From their 'COA' I tracked back to the vendor whose name and details and email address I have and who purports to be a UACC member.
I contacted them and was advised " This wonderful item was bought from a collection in the USA and comes with Cert of Authenticity from Backstage Autographs Australia as well as the original cert of Authenticity from the USA which has been verified as well. The information we have is that it was signed in early October 1979 on the last tour of the USA between the Knoxville and Atlanta venues"
I asked them if they could provide any details of the US Authenticators, and I am still awaiting a reply from April 13th.
They also had an INXS Michael Huthence signed guitar with the rest of the band for sale at the same time.
I asked a gentleman who has over 30 years association with AC/DC in a professional, social and business capacity and who in fact has specialised in Bon Scott singatures for over 20 years. Immediately the predicted answer was given that is was a fake.
His response was "The image that you attached of the autograph is a prime example of fraudulent autographs being passed off as authentic. This type of practice is common, and unfortunate, as the unsuspecting buyer is often fooled by the dealer providing "COA" (Certificate of Authenticity), when the reality of the matter is that a COA is not worth any more than the paper it is printed on.
I instantly can tell that this is a fake, and a poor one at that. Both the Bon AND the Angus signatures are fraudulent on this item"
Some poor individual paid over AUD$2000 for this item in the belief that it was genuine. In any case I recall a post from another member here asking about Bon Scott Signatures.......this is one business to avoid.
I just love the wording on their 'COA's' that states - "According to the accepted principles of the Autograph Industry we guarantee that this item has been authenticated & was signed in person & is not a copy or reprint of the artists signature" How reassured I felt after reading that. Anyway, pics are attached of this 'ultra rare' piece of AC/DC 'memorabilia'.

Comment by Steve Cyrkin Community Mgr. on March 7, 2010 at 9:13pm

I looked at a few of our examples and I agree, it's secretarial. Sorry for the disappointment. He loves theater. Why don't you heck for his upcoming play schedule and mail in-venue? Go here:
Comment by Jeffery Kite on March 7, 2010 at 8:56pm
Hey, Steve. I got this through the mail. I uses the address P.O. Box 69646, Los Angeles, CA, 90069, that I got out of the October, 2009, issue of Autograph Magazine. Now the addresses I used for Ed Asner, Ann Blyth, and Lauren Bacall from that same October, 2009, issue worked just fine, as the index cards I got back from all of those individuals passed with no problem.
Comment by Steve Cyrkin Community Mgr. on March 7, 2010 at 12:23pm
Where did you get it?
Comment by Jeffery Kite on March 7, 2010 at 11:58am
Just got back from an authentication session with THE James Spence of JSA, and this Matthew Broderick did not pass. I agreed with him, as it did not look like any of the Matthew Broderick signatures I have seen on record with JSA or PSA/DNA. I wrote the word "FAKE" on it, so please don't think that Jimmy is going around writing "FAKE" on people's stuff! :) Just thought I'd pass this along so people might could use it as an example of a fake in their exemplars.


Members (375)


© 2019   Created by Steve Cyrkin Community Mgr..   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service